Monday, March 29, 2010
Thursday, March 25, 2010
from Cathy. . .
I think the following passage explains her position on this question:
Where we are all guilty nobody is. Guilt, unlike responsibility, always singles out; it is strictly personal. It refers to an act, not intentions or potentialities. It is only in a metaphorical sense that we say we can say that we feel guilty for the sins of our fathers, or our people or mankind, in short, for deeds that we have not done.. . . (147).
By this, I think that she is saying that we can only feel vicariously responsible, because guilt requires a direct act by a single individual upon whom blame be laid. Collectively, though when groups are responsible, say in the example of an army committing war crimes, their leaders are typically to blame for massive troop crimes committed acives cording to what they felt their mission and marching orders were, as opposed to a rogue soldier acting out of line from the mission and stated tactics.
On collective responsibility Arendt writes: “No individual and personal standards of conduct will ever be able to exercise us from collective responsibility [because I think] . . . it is the price we pay for the fact that our lives are not by ourselves but among other fellow men, and that the faculty par excellence, can be actualized only in one of the many and manifold forms of human community” (157). I am having a hard time relating this to the mission of my community partner Warm Wishes, because it is difficult to convince myself that I a directly or collectively responsible for the fact that some people re homeless. Is my good fortune to be in a secure and stable position and have a home somehow contributing to the fact that some are homeless? I ask myself this question but know that those who respond to the call of my community partner for help (or not), may also have this question if they were to read Arendt’s work.
Implications of Not Thinking: absence of thinking and in re “the banality of evil”
Arendt; Responsibility and Judgement
Thinking and Moral Considerations
Hannah Arendt and the Modern Moral Standard
It would have been nice to have more time to let Arendt's concepts be absorbed upon the palate. Most of her points are arguments are drawn from other philosophical works, and are therefore it is easy to get lost within her lines of logic and reason. I have read several of Plato's works, and have fortunately read Kant and Machiavelli as well as several others she pulls her ideas from. Nevertheless, I immediately was able to connect to her concept of collective versus individual in her statement that "Where all are guilty, nobody is." It is very true! It is a way of wiping the slate clean when there has been so many wrongs committed that pointing fingers becomes useless. Also, guilt is a form of self punishment. It is the inner-dialogue we hold within ourselves when we feel that we have done wrong to others. This is what I feel Arendt is drawing attention to be connecting it to the Socratic proposition that "it is better to suffer wrong than to do wrong." But as she points out further in the reading, it implies that one or the other must exist exclusively. As if there is no option of neither being wronged or doing wrong. It is only in those marginal situations that Arendt argues that this moral proposition is valid. Yet even being valid, it can only be applicable among those of conscience who are willing to suffer. Only by being "used to living explicitly with oneself," does the argument have meaning. Those who are not connected to their conscience and self to this degree will not recognize the value in not "following the herd."
Unlike the idea of collective guilt, collective responsibility on the other hand can exist. But this is true in circumstances under which two fundamental rules apply. First, what a person is being held accountable for is for something that person has not done themselves, and that the group involved is a group to which that person cannot voluntarily be removed from. As an American citizen, for example, the actions that are taken in our name like acts of diplomacy or acts of war, speak for everyone who is here. How the world and others view us is through that lens. We are all held accountable for those actions whether or not we personally enrolled in the military or the peace corps to serve out various actions related to declarations of governmental entities. I see a bit of this collective responsibility in the work I do with my community partner. Many of the young men we work with view White people with ambivalence and distrust. To them they often represent the have-mores who make the rules for the have-nones, and their frame of reference is usually members of law enforcement or politicians with ulterior motives for offering assistance. So when I am there offering help, they are trying to figure out which of the two I am. Only after visiting on a number of occasions have they started to be open to me partaking in the meetings and events. My presence there reminds them of all the negativities in their world, so part of what I am doing there is providing an alternative view of Whites (even though I consider myself multiracial).
The way Arendt describes the thinking process and the concept of conscience, the connection is made that only "good people" are bothered by a bad conscience. This leads us back to the readings on How We Decide. Those who were capable of the most egregious violence were also very indifferent to the impact those acts of violence had on their victims and their families. They had an inability to plug into the collective emotional state. But this is a separate type of thinking than mechanical or rational thought. Many of these same criminals would test as geniuses on intelligence tests. It is the concept of empathy through connection to the collective body that permits the forms of moral precedence as laid out by Arendt.
The development of the (American) modern moral standard stems from when, as Arendt rightly states, "the emphasis shifted entirely from care for the world and the duties connected with it, to care for the soul and its salvation." We see examples of Arendt's statement in every governmental attempt to regulate morality based upon religious principles. We can also see this if we look at how Corporations are structured. They are structured as a collective to avoid responsibility as an individuals. The further away the individual is from the people directly affected by their negative (or immoral) decisions, the easier it is for them to dismiss responsibility. It is the slippery slope we slide in the insurance industry as well. The more bodies between the softer the blow of both guilt and responsibility.