I am in the middle of this week's reading, and it has brought several questions to my mind. I am thinking about education--in the broader sense, as Julia wrote--and I am trying to pinpoint how I learn things other than in the classroom. Well, reading comes to mind immediately, as does observation of how others do things. But I really think that my most creative moments of education come about because of my curiosity.
My question to myself this afternoon has been, "What is curiosity to me?" Sure, it's questioning things and ideas, but at its most fundamental, I think it is one of the things that keeps me alive. That is, it is because of curiosity that I want to see "what happens next," as if my life were a novel and each chapter or scene had a cliff-hanger. (And I don't necessarily think just of my own cliffhangers, but of those in the larger community.) Curiosity, therefore (for me, at least), keeps me young in that so many things are still new. And by young, I really mean fresh and not with a rigid mindset.
An ability not only to question things (principles, people, events, whatever) but to wonder about them are, I believe, key ingredients to foster one's curiosity. And with these components, one can grow in many different ways. For instance, curiosity can be like building blocks: this thought leads to that thought and then to another thought, and so on.
And so as I think about this, I realize what curiosity really is for me--curiosity is freedom. Freire said, "…I believe in freedom and how fundamental it is, in the exercise of freedom, to assume responsibility for our own decisions" (96). So it would seem that curiosity/freedom brings responsibilities--to think about things in a fresh way, to try to refrain from excluding others, to try to apply some of the ideas that are the byproducts of the questioning process that I call curiosity.
Usually, because I am often rather trivial, my mind is curious about things like "What would happen if a big tarantula and a scorpion were thrown together in a cage--would they fight?" Well, go onto YouTube and guess what? You can find video segments of tarantulas fighting with a variety of animal life, including scorpions. Okay, so you're probably wondering what this could possibly have to do with Freire. It's just this: I started wondering about tarantulas--just because I find them a little scary--but my fear/curiosity led me to read more and more about them. And after I read about them, I thought about them. And after I thought about them, I had an idea for a story that featured a fighting tarantula. And after I had the idea, I worked out the details--which of course led to more questions/curiosity about some other things. And when I got some more answers, I wrote an outline. And I have now written a book that features a tarantula. All this, because one day I was just curious about tarantulas. Using this same model, I continue to learn about all sorts of things.
On a more global note, in 2006 (I think), I was curious about gay marriage. I had never really thought about gay marriage--since I am not gay, I didn't find it relevant to my life. And at that time, I just went along with the status quo that marriage is between a man and a woman. But then as I thought about it, I realized that perhaps gay marriage had as much relevance to my life as, say, civil rights. And that is, that even though I didn't feel deprived of my civil rights, there certainly are many others who are or have been deprived; therefore, I decided I should really think about gay marriage and its consequences. And I did. I read other people's opinions, I talked to gay and straight friends, but I made up my own mind--although like many of my opinions, it continues to be a work in progress. I know some people probably won't agree with this, but I realized, "Who am I to say that this straight person can be married, but this gay one can't?" I may not be putting this very articulately, but what I mean is that banning gay marriage is an act of exclusion.
Other acts of exclusion--perhaps segregating schools, denying the vote to women or minorities, unequal educational opportunities because of financial circumstances, etc.--are things I find abhorrent. This also got me to thinking about slavery. So, do you think that way back when, many people accepted slavery just because it was "normal" then? And how many people back then, I wonder, were like me before I really thought about gay marriage? Did they just accept it and not really think about it? But obviously some people did think about it and found it abhorrent. Their thoughts led to underground railroads and the abolitionist movement and ultimately--at least in large part--to civil war. This, I think, really underscores what Freire talks about--that is, decision making that is aware and conscientious, "…that specifically human act of intervening in the world" (99).
Sunday, September 20, 2009
Saturday, September 19, 2009
Prompt for Pedagogy of Freedom
So, I want you to continue to think about what Freire is saying about education as something much broader than what we normally think of which is formal education. If we think about our ability to be both teachers/students in all aspects of our lives, Freire's points are still very applicable. If we are curious, then we also have to maintain a certain kind of openness to new information, and to experiences that challenge what we think we already know. This is a way of being which, I for one believe is a vital ingredient for moral growth as individuals and as societies.
Let's go back to an important concept that Freire poses in the beginning of last week's reading. He writes: "One of the biggest difficulties about this [the fact that we are always vulnerable to the transgression of others, meaning we can be violated by the unethical choices of others] ethical grounding is that we have to do everything in our power to sustain a universal human ethic without at the same time falling into a hypocritical moralism" (25). He goes on to say that this universal human ethic "calls us out of and beyond ourselves" (25).
Think about the idea of how we build understanding and trust of our shared humanity in relationship to Freire's concept of education, especially as he describes in this week's reading. Find places in the text that help you to understand the implications of his views in relationship to how we might build our capacity to find universal ethics related to human rights while not becoming "authoritarian" or dogmatic. Next, are there any ways that your service experience may already be deepening your understanding of this possibility or the complexity thereof? Or how do you anticipate that it might? Or ?
Let's go back to an important concept that Freire poses in the beginning of last week's reading. He writes: "One of the biggest difficulties about this [the fact that we are always vulnerable to the transgression of others, meaning we can be violated by the unethical choices of others] ethical grounding is that we have to do everything in our power to sustain a universal human ethic without at the same time falling into a hypocritical moralism" (25). He goes on to say that this universal human ethic "calls us out of and beyond ourselves" (25).
Think about the idea of how we build understanding and trust of our shared humanity in relationship to Freire's concept of education, especially as he describes in this week's reading. Find places in the text that help you to understand the implications of his views in relationship to how we might build our capacity to find universal ethics related to human rights while not becoming "authoritarian" or dogmatic. Next, are there any ways that your service experience may already be deepening your understanding of this possibility or the complexity thereof? Or how do you anticipate that it might? Or ?
Wednesday, September 9, 2009
Readings for 10 September 2009
Hello fellow classmates --
Getting a start on the blogging. Question: Has anyone else found the "What's It All About" reading akin to watching paint dry? I'll try again, but compared to Wm. Kaufmann I find the writing contrived and quite difficult to read. Help me change my attitude! HEIDI
Friday, May 8, 2009
From: Vladimir Nabokov’s memior, Speak Memory. . .
Whenever I start thinking of my love for a person, I am in the habit of immediately drawing radii from my love—from my heart, from the tender nucleus of a personal matter—to monstrously remote points in the universe. Something impels me to measure the consciousness of my love against such unimaginable and incalculable things as the behavior of nebulae (whose very remoteness seems a form of insanity), the dreadful pits of eternity, the unknowledgeable beyond the unknown, the helplessness, the cold, the sickening involutions and interpenetrations of space and time […] it cannot be helped […]. When that slow-motion explosion of love takes place in me, unfolding its melting fringes and overwhelming with the sense of something much vaster, much more enduring and powerful than the accumulation of matter or energy in any imaginable cosmos, then my mind cannot but pinch itself to see if it is really awake […] I have to have all space and time participate in my emotion, in my mortal love, so that the edge of its mortality is taken off, thus helping me fight the utter degradation, ridicule, and horror of having developed an infinity of sensation and thought within a finite existence . (296-297)
Sunday, April 19, 2009
From Alford's upcoming book. . .
In the introduction to After the Holocaust: The Book of Job, Primo Levi, and the Path to Affliction (to be published this year by Cambridge University Press), Alford writes:
Is is good to know and accept one's nakedness and vulnerability before fate and might so that we do not become what [Simone] Weil called a Pharisee, one who worships the empire of might, social power in all its forms. This is perhaps the hardest thing for humans to do: not to confuse goodness and might––that is, not to worship might because it is might. Yet it is essential if we are to become just and good. "Only he who knows the empire of might and knows how not to respect it is capable of love and justice" (Weil, from The Illiad or The Poem of Force)
Is is good to know and accept one's nakedness and vulnerability before fate and might so that we do not become what [Simone] Weil called a Pharisee, one who worships the empire of might, social power in all its forms. This is perhaps the hardest thing for humans to do: not to confuse goodness and might––that is, not to worship might because it is might. Yet it is essential if we are to become just and good. "Only he who knows the empire of might and knows how not to respect it is capable of love and justice" (Weil, from The Illiad or The Poem of Force)
Sunday, April 12, 2009
Whistleblowers - Ch. 3 & 4
“What academics frequently regard as virtuous, such as imagination for the situation of others, the whistleblower often experiences as a burden, an inability to do otherwise. The academic names the virtue, but the whistleblower pays the price” (67)
Arendt’s Platonic ideal “it is better to suffer wrong than to do wrong” is present when we look at the whistleblower’s stories. But Arendt never reaches the point of “choiceless-choice” (38) that the whistleblower does. Arendt uses the two-in-one dialog as a tool to arrive at one’s morality in the context of “preparing it in this way for the subsequent communication with others” (Responsibility and Judgment, 94). Because whistleblowers have no place in the organization for their internal dialog to be shared, they are “space-walking” (5), isolated. “Many whistleblowers regret this inability to stop talking with themselves, experiencing it a more as a curse than a blessing” (13).
Butler states Levinas’ “face”, or “Other”, “makes an ethical demand” on us(Precarious Life, 131), but the whistleblower’s story usually starts with “I”. In the whistleblowers' stories the ethical demand comes first from within, not from an Other. Alford calls this “narcissism moralized” (63)
In “An Imagination for Consequences” story (66), Alford says, “whistleblowers are connected in an almost visceral way with the consequences of their acts, this does not mean that they are connected in an almost visceral way with those who are affected by them” (67). He contrasts this with the behavior of “the rescuer” (67), who forms an attachment with the victim. The whistleblower’s story serves to isolate them, “the rescuer and his or her charge against the world. The whistleblower risks less, but generally risks it alone” (68). This connection with acts is also evident in Joe's "A Sense of the Historical Moment" (68) story where he "is attached not so much to others as to his acts" (69).
In the third type of story, “Identification with the Victim”, the whistleblower doesn’t identify with the Other like a rescuer does. In this story type, the whistleblower’s “identification with the victim takes the form of refusal to ally oneself with the aggressor” (71). And in the “A Sense of Shame” story type (73), the whistleblower still seems to be focused inwardly. All of Don Bloom’s statements on page 73 start with “I.” On page 74, “the just man can be shamed by the deeds of the unjust,” is a self-centered statement. All this is not to say that the whistleblowers are entirely disconnected from the Other, but it does not seem to be place they start from.
The one constant in Arendt, Butler, and The Whistleblowers is that dialog is what sets the moral human apart.
Arendt’s Platonic ideal “it is better to suffer wrong than to do wrong” is present when we look at the whistleblower’s stories. But Arendt never reaches the point of “choiceless-choice” (38) that the whistleblower does. Arendt uses the two-in-one dialog as a tool to arrive at one’s morality in the context of “preparing it in this way for the subsequent communication with others” (Responsibility and Judgment, 94). Because whistleblowers have no place in the organization for their internal dialog to be shared, they are “space-walking” (5), isolated. “Many whistleblowers regret this inability to stop talking with themselves, experiencing it a more as a curse than a blessing” (13).
Butler states Levinas’ “face”, or “Other”, “makes an ethical demand” on us(Precarious Life, 131), but the whistleblower’s story usually starts with “I”. In the whistleblowers' stories the ethical demand comes first from within, not from an Other. Alford calls this “narcissism moralized” (63)
In “An Imagination for Consequences” story (66), Alford says, “whistleblowers are connected in an almost visceral way with the consequences of their acts, this does not mean that they are connected in an almost visceral way with those who are affected by them” (67). He contrasts this with the behavior of “the rescuer” (67), who forms an attachment with the victim. The whistleblower’s story serves to isolate them, “the rescuer and his or her charge against the world. The whistleblower risks less, but generally risks it alone” (68). This connection with acts is also evident in Joe's "A Sense of the Historical Moment" (68) story where he "is attached not so much to others as to his acts" (69).
In the third type of story, “Identification with the Victim”, the whistleblower doesn’t identify with the Other like a rescuer does. In this story type, the whistleblower’s “identification with the victim takes the form of refusal to ally oneself with the aggressor” (71). And in the “A Sense of Shame” story type (73), the whistleblower still seems to be focused inwardly. All of Don Bloom’s statements on page 73 start with “I.” On page 74, “the just man can be shamed by the deeds of the unjust,” is a self-centered statement. All this is not to say that the whistleblowers are entirely disconnected from the Other, but it does not seem to be place they start from.
The one constant in Arendt, Butler, and The Whistleblowers is that dialog is what sets the moral human apart.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)