“What academics frequently regard as virtuous, such as imagination for the situation of others, the whistleblower often experiences as a burden, an inability to do otherwise. The academic names the virtue, but the whistleblower pays the price” (67)
Arendt’s Platonic ideal “it is better to suffer wrong than to do wrong” is present when we look at the whistleblower’s stories. But Arendt never reaches the point of “choiceless-choice” (38) that the whistleblower does. Arendt uses the two-in-one dialog as a tool to arrive at one’s morality in the context of “preparing it in this way for the subsequent communication with others” (Responsibility and Judgment, 94). Because whistleblowers have no place in the organization for their internal dialog to be shared, they are “space-walking” (5), isolated. “Many whistleblowers regret this inability to stop talking with themselves, experiencing it a more as a curse than a blessing” (13).
Butler states Levinas’ “face”, or “Other”, “makes an ethical demand” on us(Precarious Life, 131), but the whistleblower’s story usually starts with “I”. In the whistleblowers' stories the ethical demand comes first from within, not from an Other. Alford calls this “narcissism moralized” (63)
In “An Imagination for Consequences” story (66), Alford says, “whistleblowers are connected in an almost visceral way with the consequences of their acts, this does not mean that they are connected in an almost visceral way with those who are affected by them” (67). He contrasts this with the behavior of “the rescuer” (67), who forms an attachment with the victim. The whistleblower’s story serves to isolate them, “the rescuer and his or her charge against the world. The whistleblower risks less, but generally risks it alone” (68). This connection with acts is also evident in Joe's "A Sense of the Historical Moment" (68) story where he "is attached not so much to others as to his acts" (69).
In the third type of story, “Identification with the Victim”, the whistleblower doesn’t identify with the Other like a rescuer does. In this story type, the whistleblower’s “identification with the victim takes the form of refusal to ally oneself with the aggressor” (71). And in the “A Sense of Shame” story type (73), the whistleblower still seems to be focused inwardly. All of Don Bloom’s statements on page 73 start with “I.” On page 74, “the just man can be shamed by the deeds of the unjust,” is a self-centered statement. All this is not to say that the whistleblowers are entirely disconnected from the Other, but it does not seem to be place they start from.
The one constant in Arendt, Butler, and The Whistleblowers is that dialog is what sets the moral human apart.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteFor what Alford calls this “narcissism moralized” (63), I would add that this could be an universal position for both the whistleblower and the rescuer, if none of them is conscious of that. Are they doing for themselves or for others? Do they, deep inside, seek for recognition about what they did (could be the Narciso's mirror: good job!)?
ReplyDeleteAlford also says, “whistleblowers are connected in an almost visceral way with the consequences of their acts, this does not mean that they are connected in an almost visceral way with those who are affected by them” (67), as mentioned by Steve above, also contrasting this with the behavior of “the rescuer” (67), who forms an attachment with the victim. I would add that the attachment of the rescuer is micro, while the attachment of the whistleblower is macro: as put by Janet Morgan in her story: "When I finally figured out what we were doing to the poor people who were our clients,I couldn't even go out for a drink with them anymore. (...) I didn't even know our client's names, but I had to choose." (69) She didn't know the rescued, but she easily could "feel their feeling, feel their pain" and she couldn't take part in that. This identification without a face is common to many of them and necessary to their action. Without the identification, micro or macro, there would be no reaason to blow the whistle.
Later, in the book, Alford states that the identification with the victim turns the whistleblower unable to align with the agressor. But that is, in fact, an inability to be double (71). The inability to be double send us back to the narcissism moralized again: morally I can just be one in order to admire myself.
Again, Socrates main idea of "it is better to suffer wrong, than to do wrong" comes back to light. This is the backbone of morality and ethic.
Whistleblowers are sort of "unaware people"; they act morally without reasoning about that. That also comes back when they say they are ashamed of working for agencies/companies that careless about the public/clients (73). They use the word shame exactly because they are unaware of the morality they are seeking in their jobs; doing business with moral and ethics.
I thought a great deal on the whistleblowers' motives in this section. I guess I am fascinated with their thoughts going into action and what exactly think they can accomplish. Do they go into a situation with high hopes and determination that they will make a difference, or are they trying to make things for the better but know that it can bring a failure on their part? I found Alford's points on transforming situations into inspiring tales to be extremely vital. Alford says that the Frankfurt School of Critical Theory, "made a similar argument about aesthetics: any artistic rendering of the horrible and grotesque must misrepresent it by making it beautiful, in form if not content, for that is (dare one say it) the nature of Art (Marcuse 1978)," (Alford, 38). I like how this is related to Whistleblowers, but to art as well. With dance, we believe dance is already beautiful, but if we bring aspects of suffering and ugliness to the movement, we are taking it to another level by engaging the viewer. This can alter it to a whole other beauty.
ReplyDeleteWhistleblowers don't want to believe that things will continue to go on falsely, and I think this is why they are so adamant about using their narrative to benefit their actions. One theme Alford talks about is the choiceless choice. I've always thought that a Choiceless Choice requires letting go of pressuring ourselves into making a decision this red hot moment. The Choiceless Choice is done by making no choice until clarity arises to move us in a certain direction. How can you live with yourself when you know you are working in a false reality knowing there is a small chance that you can change that for not only yourself, but for the company and other employees. If anything, these whistleblowers' are showing us HOW to live. Do we live falsely by not speaking our truths to protect ourselves? Alford says, "The answer is that a choiceless choice is a formula for relief from the almost unbearable regret of having let oneself be sent on a suicide mission," (Alford, 40).
I appreciate Alford’s’ honesty and his ideas on the fact that how much we learn greatly depends on how much we are willing to give up. I see this theme in everyday life, because I am so willing to change for the better, that I know the only way I can get there is to give up my old habit, my old perceptions of myself and others, and be willing to take a risk to bring about good.
Before reading this book, I have never heard of the term whistleblower. After learning what it means, I don't think it is a horrible term. I think that if there wasn't a need for whistleblowers then our society wouldn't have to have them. Unfortunately or fortunately, we do and I don't mind that we do. I do mind how they are treated by other people.
ReplyDeleteI feel that it is probably safe to say that most members of our society do not appreciate how severely most whistleblowers are treated. Ignorance about this travesty has two implications. First, something needs to be done to protect whistleblowers, and, second, people need to know what they are getting into before they decide to blow the whistle.
I feel that Alford tries to weave a consistent model of whistleblowing to his audience that builds on the concepts of individuality and ego ideal in order to help us understand why whistleblowers feel like space-walkers who have been ostracized not just from the organization but also from everyone in society, including thier family and friends.
Maybe it is society's fault for making them feel this way. They are people who are just doing their jobs. They are doing what they feel is the right thing to do. If something isn't right, it is up to someone to make it better. If that means telling on someone or a company in order to make a positive change, then I think it should be applauded, not scolded.
I have a great deal of sympathy for whistleblowers because from reading this book I'm beginning to realize that my mom was well on the path of being one if she wasn't already coincidered one. She is a student in a fairly new program at a University and she has been speaking out about unfair policies and grading that is going on. I believe that at first she thought they were happening by mistake but as she started to learn the truth and realized that some of the faculty and administration actually knew what they were doing even though it was wrong, and were ok with it, she lost a lot of faith. While initially it did concern her and her close classmates she started to realize that she wanted to fix the problems not only for current students and those who were forced to leave, but for future students investing their time and money into that school. While my mom hasn't been kicked out yet, they were threatening her and made her repeat the entire year when she was less than half a point away from passing(based on their calculations). She has only recently backed down not because she is ok with what they are doing but because she wants to be able to complete school and not have all of these past years and money go to waste. She is not willing to let them make her give up her dream so she’s backing down on the fight.
ReplyDeleteI feel like my mom views this as a "choiceless choice." She feels like she was chosen to go up against the school because there are so many younger students who want to but are unwilling. For a while she was feeling like a hero. Receiving support from fellow students and even some faculty, however when it came down to having their consent and support when actually talking to the University they were silent. They were not there for her. She felt alone.
She started to get very depressed. She felt like the last few years of her life she spent in a corrupt school were wasted years and wasted dollars. She found comfort in sharing her story over and over again with anyone who would listen. I get the sense that she was "stuck in static time." She wasn't allowing herself to move forward. Now I can hear my mom sounding a bit more like the whistleblower quoted on page 39; "Even though I lost my trust in authority, it restored my trust in myself. I believe in myself now. I don't need to believe in anybody else." This was by no means an easy place for her to get to and times were unpleasent for the entire family before she reached this place.
I do believe that whistleblowers serve a purpose in society. I also realize how hard it is to be one and how it affects ones family and life. While I wouldn’t recommend it, I know that I would totally do it if it were for an issue that I was passionate about. I would feel better about myself knowing that I spoke out rather than let it go by. I think it takes a certain type of person to take on that position. Usually a leader or someone who views themself as strong. However they don’t always find that strength again in the end.
Narcissism Moralized and the Ego Ideal
ReplyDeleteAlford’s discussion on narcissism in the context of the whistleblower is highly illuminating not only of the whistleblower but of the average Joe (or Joe the Plumber) as well. Here in only a few pages we have a comprehensive discussion of human motivation and morality.
In this overview of highly complex psychological concepts, it is Alford’s narratives, in other words, his stories of whistleblowers that make this material so accessible to one such as me.
It is the value of the story in shaping our sense of self and identifying patterns with which to “order our existence.” as Richard Norman, in an earlier reading said.
What stands out for me is that the “avatar of primary narcissism,” (p.78) the ego ideal, seems to be rooted in decisions we make. Whether our actions are perceived as moral or immoral, has to do with whether our ego ideal is good.
“Narcissism moralized requires that the content of the ego ideal, that is, one’s ideals – become moral. We worship the gods because they are good, says Socrates, not because it is good to worship the gods (p.78). This to me indicates that we have a choice to chose whether our motivations to act are good (based on accepted models of good.
“Narcissism as a special kind of anger… Plato calls, thumos: The human spirit that feels indignation at baseness and corruption” (p78).
This seems to me, what Jesus of Nazareth exhibited in the temple when overthrowing the tables of the money-changers. And it is argued among various theologians (sorry no quotes) that this is the only exhibit of anger that can be attributed to Jesus, one against the corrupt.
So thumos, for which we have no direct translation in English may very well be the most righteous of indignations. And the whistleblower is perhaps tapping into the very essence of righteous anger… unfortunately, that in turn is what may give the whistleblower his appearance of narcissism, or self-righteousness.
I felt rage over injustice once. It lasted for a long time. People turned away from me just as in Alford’s stories. It had to do with the treatment of children unrelated to me and everyone told me it was none of my business. Even I, in my rational mind, thought it might be none of my business. But because it had to do with children a sense of rage built up so strongly in me, I was driven seemingly without reason to do everything in my power to seek attention for the situation. I was obsessed. It was awful. I did damage to my health. But the worst of it was the self-absorption, the narcissism, if you will. At that time there were no suitable explanations as to why I couldn’t let it go. Now in little over three pages, Alford lays it all out to ponder and reflect upon. A type of healing is administered so many years later. God I love books!
In Whistleblowers, Alford uses the narratives of the whistleblowers to demonstrate how they have become “stuck in a static of time”, or their “narratives lack resolution”(p.60). In his notes (p.146), Alford writes that his most reliable sources for the stories in Whistleblowers came to him “more like diaries that essays or novels.” He writes about how they are constantly replaying the events that unfolded, always in a linier fashion. The whistleblower relates everything else that has happened and will happen in their lives as a result of their act. Alford writes, “ Most whistleblowers’ narratives seems stuck in time or imprisoned in a closed universe in which everything refers to everything else, with nothing left over for the world. A few whistleblowers’ sounded free, but hardly in the conventional sense” (57).
ReplyDeleteThe whistleblowers, especially when negative consequences are reaped because of their action, are unable to understand why their actions are not seen as righteous. If the act itself was, as Alfords states “a choiceless choice”, is the whistleblower ever really able to make sense of what happened? Even when the wrong they set out to right is taken care of the whistleblower still live in a world that it is shattered. The act that the whistleblower committed killed the life they once knew.
If it is a case of the whistleblower being a “narcissist moralized” and he or she only taking action to make themselves look better, so what. If a person takes action when they see injustice does not matter if it is because he or she can’t live with themselves or they fear for the well being of someone else, it is still a noble act and should be rewarded as such. It is a noble voice from within that dictates actions such as the case of Ron Ridenhour (p.78) that Alford writes about. When Ridenhour blew the whistle on the massacre at My Lai, he did so out of disgust and shame. His contempt and sorrow for what the military had forced his comrades in to left him with anger for his superiors, and this anger at his superiors is necessary for Ridenhour to try and make sense of what had happened. It is in this context that Ridenhour could “live as if one (Ridenhour) is already dead”(p.58). The act that the whistleblower committed killed the life he once knew.
Retreat or Attack?
ReplyDeleteAlford throughout his whole book illuminates the idea that being a whistleblower more likely than not means that you are going to lose everything. I understand the idea of standing up for your beliefs, I think many of short stories we read earlier in the book about whistleblowers were very courageous. However in chapter 3 and 4, Alford shares stories about many people not having the same positive outcomes. Perhaps this is a result of them being trapped in their own vanities or as Alford mentions, "narcissism."
Our teacher in our last class talked about how the whistleblowers thought that the companies would do the right thing in the end. It turns out from Alford's book, the companies really never do the right things, and the whistleblowers lose their jobs, their families and friends, their whole lives. At what point do you point on the gloves and step back from begin a whistleblower and become a virus, ready to attack the heart of the organization. If you are willing to give up your family to prove your point, I would think there would be no limit to what else you would do to correct this problem. If the corporation is constantly shutting you down, and turning your friends and families against you, why not bring your arguments to the public, where the corporations would take the biggest hit?
It seems the whistleblowers tend to react defensively, rather than offensively. They are consumed about self-image, and how they are portrayed in the eyes of others. They need to let this go of these fears. If you really want to get your point across, you might have to play the part of the villain. This is how I think you would have a possible chance of defeating an organization.
When does the whistleblower really win? As illustrated by Alford stories of Amy Brown and Mike Quint, even if the whistleblower is vindicated they still feel as though they have lost something a lot more important than their jobs and certainly more irreplaceable. They have lost their faith and trust in people. “Once they know this, or rather once one feels this knowledge in one’s bones, one lives in a new world forever.”(52) This is sadly similar to the whistleblower who is never vindicated and lives a life stuck in his own story. Being that stories are defined by their end, and the end for whistleblowers appears to almost always be tragic in nature, it makes sense that they cannot seem to get to the end when retelling it, and allow themselves to get distracted by the minute details. “One could argue that it is because the whistleblower doesn’t know the meaning of his story that he cannot bring to a stop the endless sequence of events. On the contrary, I argue that it is preciously because he does know that he cannot find the end”. (48)
ReplyDeleteI believe that whistleblowers have many different motives for making the decision to act. However, once they start the process it appears to take on a life of its own. “What is clear about moral narcissism is its power. Not to many things will make a man or woman give up everything for his or her beliefs, but wounded narcissism is one.”(79)
I have compassion for the whistleblower and I identify with being stuck in static time,and the inability to bring the story to an end for fear of finally knowing its meaning.
Most people believe that what is free is what making your own choices all about. "Bower concluded, I'm glad id did not have a choice. I do not think I could live with myself if I thought I chose all this." One might argue that this proves Bower did have a choice. His experience of actions show this. One would say perhaps he is avoiding the responsibilities of his actions.
ReplyDelete"Choiceless choice is as close as many whistleblowers get to evaluating their own narratives. Evaluation is not about stating the moral of the story. Evaluation is about telling the story in such a way that the listener comes to believe that is has a point, that it starts somewhere, stops somewhere else, and that one has learned something along the way. The most adventageous judgements are not stapled on, but are in the story itself. Recurrently this is done by comparators. These people try to move away from the story to rethink ungrasped likelihoods. "Choiceless choice is a comparator in disguise: The person had no choice and juxtaposing another possibility as stupid.
Alas, choiceless choise institutes affliction. There can not be a healthy communication between sender and the donee. However, their struggle makes our world.