Tuesday, November 1, 2011

Adam Phillips and Barbara Taylor, the authors of On Kindness, posed some very interesting questions and observations. For example, both authors began by asking “Why do the pleasures of kindness astonish us? And why are the stories about kindness often so corny or silly, so trivializing of the things that matter most?”(pg4). As it turns out, kindness was a huge staple in the past. According to Adam Phillips and Barbara Taylor “History shows us the manifold expressions of humanity’s desire to connect, from classical celebrations of friendship, to teachings on love and charity” (pg7) and kindness was considered “mankind’s greatest delight” (pg4). So I guess kindness isn’t such a corny gesture after all. In today’s society there is a complete lack of kindness. Why? While reading, I discovered that showing kindness is considered a “bold” and “gutsy” move. “Most people, as they grow up now, secretly believe that kindness is a virtue of losers.”(pg9) I don’t agree!!!! In my opinion, I believe that we have developed a huge fear of rejection and vulnerability. Technology has also severely limited our range of communication skills and has aided in the development of vast egotistical attitudes. It’s as if we have lost the ability to show compassion towards our fellow man. However, we expect kindness to be generously and freely given to us without being reciprocated. I believe that if one is shown kindness, kindness should be given in return. However, the feelings of rejection and vulnerability shouldn’t entirely limit our ability to show kindness.

Kindness of out love-Jessica D.

Some perceive vulnerability as something negative because it involved weakness. But how come people don’t see kindness as a negative even though it involves vulnerability and weakness to some degree? Many people, adults especially, have grown to become aware of the harsh realities and cruelties of the world. People become guarded. I agree that often in our society, “Kindly behavior is looked upon with suspicion” (7). It’s not that when people see kindness, they automatically think “vulnerability and weakness,” but rather ask, “Why is he/she being so kind? Something must be in it for him/her.” Crimes in the media nowadays have conditioned the people to think that kindness is rare, so if someone sees kindness in everyday life they assume there’s a hidden motive behind it.

“Kindness opens us up to the world of other people in ways that we both long for and dread” (12). Fear of the unknown. But I think this is where selflessness comes into the picture. When we look past this fear, we can focus on the mountain of goodness that will come out of our kindness to others, and that will give us courage to overcome suspicion. I don’t believe that “When God is dead, kindness is permitted… kindness is all that people have left” (13), but rather God is the root of kindness. God allows unfortunate events to happen like the loss of loved ones and devastating natural disasters, because essentially it causes humanity to turn towards each other. Even at times when one doesn’t feel God’s presence, it doesn’t mean that God ceases to exist.

I think this is why most of the students in MMCS are so guarded. They see our service as tutors and often ask why we’re doing it and why we even care. Many perceive the acts of kindness done out of obligation rather than out of love. Many of them think we’re just there to get school credits, but I can honestly say my experience is much more than that. My relationship with God encourages my everyday acts of kindness because it’s out of love.

Spread Le Kindness

This piece really calls society out. What I mean by that is that I feel On Kindness makes us realizes that kindness IS okay, that we should actually be doing it more often. It seems as if because we have become more independent and individualistic, we have lost some sense of our empathy because we have been trained not to depend on others. The push to be independent as well as the push to not depend on others has paved a path that seems to not have room for kindness. If we are kind to others, we may be preventing them from being able to be independent themselves or as the reading stated, others will see our vulnerability. 'Kindness that is, the ability to bear the vulnerability of others and therefore of oneself-- has become a sign of weakness.' (9) I see this quote in action all too often and so I asked myself, why is it hard to be kind? Personally, sometimes I shy away from doing acts of kindness because I do feel vulnerable, vulnerable that they will take advantage of me or that they will shun me, as well as my kindness, away. Again as a society, we don't want to feel vulnerable to others and we definitely don't want to be rejected by others either. Also as this quote states 'Kindness is seen either as a cover story or as a failure of nerve' (8). Sometimes it's hard to believe that others are capable of being kind without an alternative motive. Therefore, when we are doing 'overly kind' things, they may come off as fake because we 'want to be liked by all' or we are simply 'scared' so we cater to everyone. In today's cutthroat society, it's hard to believe that some people are kind because they want to be or just because that's who they are. How can a stranger be kind when there is so much hate and anger circulating the universe? Because of the vulnerability, the rejection, and the suspected alternative motives, there is no wonder people have been unable to express kindness publicly. 'People are leading secretly kind lives all the time but without a language in which to express this, or cultural support for it' (4). As a society, we need to start the movement that kindness is okay, and that if someone does reject your kind act, they at least had an experience with a kind stranger.
Further, as the article said, 'We are never as kind as we want to be, but nothing outrages us more than people being unkind to us. There is nothing we feel more consistently deprived of than kindness; the unkindness of others has become our contemporary complaint. Kindness consistently preoccupies us, and yet most of us are unable to live a life guided by it' (10). We must apply the GOLDEN RULE, that most of us have learned in kindergarten; Treat others the way you would want to be treated. We cannot expect others to reveal their vulnerability and risk getting rejected and judged if we do not do the same. It just makes sense. But then, no one wants to make the first move because, what if no one joins the cause? Then they would be the only one standing for something and would be embarrassed and again, vulnerable. But we are talking about kindness here people! When others are nice to you, it creates a chain reaction and as a result we want to be nice to everyone the rest of the day which in turn affects all of them too!

'A competitive society, one that divides people into winners and losers, breeds unkindness' (105). I fear that our world has become so focused on big concepts and advancements that when they are fronted with simple ideas such as kindness, they freeze and are unable to process whether or not it is an idea they want to take into action. Of course there are going to be winners and losers, but we all need to fail once in a while to remind us that we still need to work hard and that we must still contribute to the world. As hard as it may be, we need to start trying to look past the grade, the championship, the money and the success and think about how we are going to get there. Are we going to go on a kind journey, one where we acknowledge and enjoy the company of others? Or will we simply trek along, all by our lonesome known as 'the mean one.' 'People think that they envy other people for their success, money, fame, when in fact it is kindness that is most envied, because it is the strongest indicator of people's well-being, their pleasure in existence' (111). If you are doing well and you are happy as can be, SPREAD THE KINDNESS. You'll be happier knowing that you've positively influence someone and think about all of the ripple effects you'll have created.

An Examination of Kindness

This week we were asked to read two chapters that proved to be both interesting and meaningful in their content. The readings consisted of the first and last chapter of On Kindness by Adam Phillips and Barabara Taylor. As the title suggests, the chapters provided an in-depth examination of kindness, particularly how kindness is relevant to everyday life.

In the first chapter, Phillips and Taylor begin their argument that kindness is a truly pleasurable activity (4). Some evidence they provide includes a quote by Theodor Adorno, who declared “No less indiscriminate and general than the alienation between people is the desire to breach it” (6). The authors expound upon this idea of alienation versus communal kindness, defining kindness as “the ability to bear the vulnerability of others, and therefore of oneself” (8). It is suggested that kindness is equated with weakness in modern times as a result of this vulnerability (8). This is taken a step further when Phillips and Taylor infer that vulnerability is an essential element of the individual that helps tie humanity together (11-12).

Phillips’ and Taylor’s assessment of kindness is continued throughout the final chapter of their book. The authors open with a quote to introduce their next point: despite the modern desire for independence, being sympathetic and needing others is part of what it means to be human (95-96). Shortly into the chapter, a 1970 study by Richard Titmuss is used as further support that humans are inherently kind. The study involved a poll of British blood donors, where 98.2 percent of the donors “said they did it to assist someone whom they would never meet” (100). Phillips and Taylor staunchly maintain this position of inherent kindness for the duration of the chapter, contending opposition such that kindness is an impossible goal for the masses or that people are kind to make them feel better about themselves (110-111).

To a large degree, I feel the claims Phillips and Taylor make are valid. There are countless examples of people deriving great enjoyment from helping others and ultimately feeling that their life is more fulfilling. For me, it is essentially this aspect that causes me to enjoy and value service projects like the volunteer work I am doing for Coleman Elementary school. It is also the reason I would like to have a career of providing people with a meaningful service by becoming a physician.

- Christopher Galbick

Kindness Lost in Humanity

American society in this day and age can be described in one word: Individualistic.  Our society focuses on the individual and making oneself happy; rather than focusing on the community and making others happy.  It makes sense that this is a fairly new concept in history, considering the fact that America is a fairly new country created through the radical ideals of making individual rights the number one priority.  However, in this new era of "self centered" thinking, we tend to overlook the simple things which truly bring happiness in our lives.  The authors of "On Kindness" bring this up in their book, and discuss the reasoning behind it.  Contrary to common thinking that all humans are "...mad, bad, and dangerous to know; that as a species...we are deeply and fundamentally antagonistic to each other, that our motives are utterly self-seeking, and that our sympathies are forms of self-protection," the authors of this book argue otherwise(4).  According to them, "...the kind life - the life lived in instinctive sympathetic identification with the vulnerabilities and attractions of others -  is the life we are more inclined to live, and indeed is the one we are often living without letting ourselves know that this is what we are doing" (4). 
The authors address the fact that "Independence and self-reliance are not the great aspirations..." and kindness is feared because it makes us vulnerable.  Kindness is viewed as a trait of weakness in most people, except for the exceptionally kind who we see as saintly or God-like.  In today's society, we are taught that we must be strong and resilient in order to make it in the world and that being weak and vulnerable is simply proof that we are pathetic.  In order to be kind we must be vulnerable, and "bearing other people's vulnerability -  which means sharing in it imaginatively and practically without needing to get rid of it, to yank people out of it - entails being able to bear one's own" (11).  I can directly link this fear of vulnerability with my experience at MCCS.  The authors' explanations as to why people are less kind to others can be seen in real life with the students at the school.  Their disrespect towards their teachers, their supervisors, and their peers stem from their fear of being labeled as vulnerable.  If one student is kind to his or her teacher, then the other students more than likely will point it out and think of that student as being weak.
The chapter entitled "Modern Kindness" discusses humanity's transition from valuing kindness above all else to valuing one's self above all else.  Although we have been conditioned to believe that we are independent creatures who need not rely on anyone else but themselves, the truth is that "...we are all dependent creatures, right to the core..." and "Individualism is a very recent phenomenon" (96).  Humans are innately kind and care for one another.  An obvious example is the kindness apparent between a parent and child.  A mother does not need an excuse to be kind to her child, it is just natural.  Kindness stems from the individual, however "A competitive society, one that divides people into winners and losers, breeds unkindness" (105).  If we can break free from the chains of society and truly live as humans, then kindness will no longer be put on the back burner and humanity may be able to reconnect with its true ways.

On Kindness

The first chapter seemed very familiar to me in a sense that the author put an emphasis on how hard it is to open up and become vulnerable to other people. Last blog post, the line "we are undone by each other" really stuck out to me. I think it really relates to this reading. By being kind to someone, one is opening up, becoming vulnerable. That's what makes kindness so hard is that no one wants to be vulnerable around other people. Vulnerability nowadays is perceived as a weakness. "In one sense kindness is always hazardous because it is based on a susceptability to others, a capacity to identify with their pleasures and sufferings" (5). It's a good example of humanity, to allow oneself to be vulnerable enough to share in one's pleasures and sufferings. An example to tie into my service is probably my willingness to be vulnerable to the kids. It's weird how one can become so attatched, especially after gaining perspective to what molds them to be the way they are. Perhaps this is cliche but I get a sort of warm feeling when I know they retain something I have tried to teach them. I feel like little by little I'm sort of making a difference.

The final chapter underlines the history of the transition from being kind to being individualistic. The authors discuss various modern aspects of kindness. They view kindness in comparison to "godlike kindness," they look at kindness through heriability, and they look at what kindness is latently. Though I understand it isn't a real big point, I am intrigued by the idea that "kindness is a disguised form of sexuality" (111). Rather, I think that sometimes kindness is a disguised form of desire. For instance, sometimes kids are nicer to their parents when they know they have to ask for something. It's the same idea at Coleman. The kids are a little bit sweeter when they know they have to ask for help or they want something. I think it ties back to the beginning of this chapter. People are dependent creatures even though they seek to be self-sufficient. "Feelings of connection and reciprocity are among the greatest pleasures that human beings can possess" (111). I feel like this does hold true. Although I am being required to do this service, at the end of the day it does feel rewarding. I feel like my service is a two-way street and is a form of reciprocity because I form relationships with everyone.

Kind lives

It astonishes me how much these articles relate to our first class meeting, where we defined what ethics and morals were and how they applied to us. I'll never forget going over some basic "human rules" we expected of ourselves and each other. No killing, no stealing, no cheating... and then Jessica raised her hand and flat out said, "Love." To love others and to be loved in return is something we all crave and strive for. But for some reason, "an image of the self has been created that is utterly lacking in natural generosity. Most people appear to believe that deep down they (and other people) are mad, bad, and dangerous to know..." (4)

In society, this battle looks like this: our socioeconomic patterns, lifespan development 'norms', and our own media tells us to live an autonomic, independent life. On the flip side, movies and songs speak of unbreakable, everlasting love and we watch, yearning to feel that way, and then complain on Facebook that we are "forever alone". Even in my own life I can see how this battle is being played out. I want to believe that because my actions are good, or at least, I'm not killing anyone, that I am a good person, but then there will be times that I don't feel like I am what my actions tell me I am.

This brings me to the conclusion that kindness and love are deeper than the mere action. And the thing is, "people are leading secretly kind lives all the time but without a language in which to express this, or a cultural support for it." (4) So what does this mean to us? It means we have shrouded kindness behind a dark cloak, and we have become so accustomed to the cloak that we forgot what was actually behind it. And looking behind the cloak, has become dangerous.

Bringing this back to my service at MCCS, I feel that I see this pattern in not only the kids, but in all us mentors. I'm sure some of us have realized the line between us and them has really been a bridge of kindness and have bravely crossed it without knowing, but I will go into more detail with my time there. Honestly, as fun as it has been, is has been one of the most challenging things I have ever done in my life. It's scary to try to reach out to someone. Again, it's the idea of being vulnerable and open to another life that scares us, because to be vulnerable means to be unprotected. (Side note: where did we even get that idea from? Humanity surprises me sometimes.) Going back to one of my students there, why did he just reach out to me when idealistically, I was supposed to be the one reaching out to him? I mean, aren't those the roles we play, the mentor and their mentoree. The teacher and the student. But in reality, he reached out to me.

This makes me ask myself, does he know something that I don't? Chances are, he does. He might not even know it, but he knows something about kindness and has taught me. Donald Winnicott writes, "A sign of health in the mind is the ability of one individual to enter imaginatively and accurately into the thoughts and feelings and hopes and fears of another person; also to allow the other person to do the same to us." (95) The authors of On Kindness go on to write, "To live well,w e must be able to imaginatively identify with other people, and allow them to identify with us." (95) The thing about kindness and vulnerability is that the actions make us feel good, not because we identify kindness with positive things, but because they allow us to be CONNECTED and FEEL that connection, with others!

To me, that's what I feel is most important about this piece, that we realize that kindness is "not a temptation to sacrifice ourselves, but to include ourselves with others." (114)