Tuesday, October 4, 2011

A Real Chance

When I think of the children who have grown up in situations where they have to fight for survival, it makes me sad. It makes me angry. They are victims, born into a society with an invisible caste system that is almost impossible to escape. Should one blame the parents, the neighborhood, the schools, the society, the government, or all of them? I believe that Canada blamed all of them to an extent, but the only thing that an outside source can really change is a child’s schooling. That is the easiest and most effective way to get a child on the right track to success. Canada was motivated by the knowledge that he could make an impact on the lives of the children that nobody had given any thought to. Separate but equal is NOT equal and Canada realized this. By opening his school, he was giving these underprivileged kids a new chance at life. But he didn’t stop there; he believed that by getting the neighborhood involved, this school may even have the possibility of one day turning the whole community around. His ideas were not sugar coated either. He knew that there were other influences that could hurt the students. He hoped that by enrolling as many children as possible into his school that kids would hang around other kids who got the same good education and they would encourage each other to succeed rather than drag each other down into the prisons of drugs and gangs. To Canada, “what mattered was the overall impact he was able to have on the children he was trying to serve.”

I’m going to do a complete jump in my discussion because I don’t want to leave out one of the topics of the readings that I agreed with most and that made this reading so interesting to me. I do not hide my feelings about kids. A few loud, ill-behaved children have ruined the whole idea of having kids of my own. For example, the reason I hate going to a big box store is because I get hit by wild kids with carts or get stuck in line next to a screaming six-year-old. But in truth, I don’t dislike kids; I blame their parents for not knowing how to raise them. I also believe that you can’t necessarily put all of the blame on the parents for not doing something if they don’t know they should be doing it. I thought it was great that Canada had set up classes for parents to teach them the best parenting skills to help mold their children into bright, respectful citizens. These classes included “nine Saturdays in a row, four or five hours a day, discussing immunization schedules and asthma prevention and the importance of reading and singing to your baby. The discipline classes, especially, were real eye openers, where [a mother in Harlem] learned about time-outs and alternatives to corporal punishment.”(P. 14) This seems obvious to those who experienced this from their parents but if they didn’t experience it, how are they supposed to know that they should do this, that, and the other for their child. Tough said that the discipline classes were the greatest eye openers for one of the mothers. She probably disciplined her child the same way she had been disciplined. Parents raise their kids in the same way they were raised. That’s all they know. Every parent wants their child to succeed but perhaps the parents don’t know what they are doing right or wrong without somebody teaching them. I really believe that every new parent should attend parenting classes. Even if they just take one thing from the classes, at least that is one more opportunity for a child.

~C. Standridge-Folsom

The Man and the Starfish

This is the first time I have ever heard of Geoffrey Canada and I cannot understand how I could have gone nineteen years without ever hearing about such a selfless and compassionate man. His motivation to help kids get on the right track and his refusal to let one child go without opportunity is just wonderful!

'So Canada chose the obvious remedy: he drew up a waiting list, and it quickly filled with the names of children who needed his help and couldn't get it.. If all he was doing was picking some kids to save and letting the rest fail, what was the point?' When I read this, I immediately thought about the story of the man and the starfish. Basically, starfish would wash up on shore and because they couldn't get back into the ocean themselves, they would eventually die. A man went around tossing the washed up starfish back into the ocean and would do this everyday even though there were too many for him to save them all. A girl asks the man why he even bothered and who would it make a difference to. The man replied 'It makes a difference to this one' as he cast the starfish back into the ocean. Canada's motivation and passion to help the children of Harlem is extremely noble and as shown through the loyalty of some of the participants in Baby College, he was making a difference. Yet he still felt the burden of those who did not have the opportunity. His drive to finish and succeed with the program even after the resistance is ridiculously incredible.

What motivates him? I could easily say that it was because he had an experience similar to those he was trying to help. Or I could say that he is just incredibly philanthropic and that helping others gives him satisfaction. I could even theorize that it's because he wants to make the world easier to get involved in, to allow everyone the same equal opportunities. But to be honest, I feel that it is so much deeper than anyone could really explain. He's not done with he helps a few hundred children and their parents, he always feels that he has more to do. Although Canada is making a difference and is positively affecting those in rough situations, he doesn't feel that he is doing enough. During the lottery he gave hope to 200 parents and students but his main concern are those who were not picked. Canada's heart is in this program completely and unconditionally because he not only strives to help those in his program but also grieves with the families he cannot provide for.

Teresa Ashby definitely reminds me of Geoffrey Canada. In the beginning, I thought it was admirable of her to spend her own money and time to devote to a group of young moms. As I began volunteering, I saw the lack of appreciation and the occasionally rude comments that brought down the morale of the group. Soon, I began to have this myopic, judgmental view of the young moms of Marin. However, at the next meeting, things changed. I took some extra time out to help them with a rummage sale on a Saturday and I immediately saw a change in their attitudes. Everyone was working together to make the afternoon a success and after I left I was thanked with genuine appreciation. Then, the next class meeting Teresa shares the difficult stories of the girls who I only saw for face value. I thought that I went into the program without judgment, but it was obvious that I became blinded by my own experiences. Teresa has such undying compassion for these girls. She gives so much to the group and continues to give knowing that she may never get anything in return. Even when she does not receive a 'thank you' or symbol of appreciation, she, like Canada, carries the burdens of these girls in her heart and does not abandon them. 'There's just no way that in good conscience we can allow poverty to remain the dividing line between success and failure in this country, where if you're born poor in a community like this one, you stay poor. We have to even that out. We ought to give these kids a chance' (pg. 18). Teresa mentioned that this world was made for adults and she was just trying to level the playing field. Both Teresa and Canada see how unfair and divided the world is becoming and are only trying to break that tradition.

As I look back, I realize how close-minded and arrogant I was. I truly did have the best intentions at heart, but I thought that the 'making a difference' part was going to be a one-way street. However rude and ignorant this statement may be, I thought 'How could this group of strangers make a difference in my life?' Yasmin spoke about how she got more out of it that the students but I again brushed it off thinking that it wouldn't apply to my experience. Now here I am only a few weeks into it and I find myself having a completely different perspective. I once worried that I would take the burdens of these families home with me and that it would be detrimental to my emotional and mental health. I thought that I could simply drop by once a week and then easily walk away from the drama of their lives. But I have taken some of these burdens home with me, and instead of feeling weighed down by their troubles, I feel hopeful that they will find success. These mothers who I had once thought were immature have already seen enough in their early years than I may ever experience in my lifetime. How Teresa is able to look past their exteriors and provide a safe haven for them before she even knew their individual stories is unbelievable. Like I said earlier with Canada, the desire to help others as deeply and as lovingly as Teresa has is driven by a force that they themselves may not be able to pinpoint. Because why, in general, are some people more altruistic than destructive? Is it because the individual is doing it for self-gratification? Or do we as humans have an innate need to help others who are struggling? I don't believe that the central or most important question is why they do it, I just love that they do.

True love of neighbor- Jessica D.

“They had to survive adolescence…” (4)

I had a mental flashback when I read this quote from Paul Tough's Whatever It Takes. I remembered when I walked into the MCC office after tutoring and overheard a conversation between a staff member and a parent of a student. He said, “I don’t want to lose my son.” That single sentence resonated with me the whole day. I realized that MCC was not only a school, but in many ways a safe haven for students. It keeps them off the streets where they could’ve been potentially dealing drugs and getting involved in gangs. For parents like the one in the office, those 5 or so hours that their kids are off the streets are a difference between life and death.

Protect life. If people internalize this gravity to help people like MCC students, they would be compelled to take action. Geoffrey Canada is one of those people who have not only embraced this greater call but also devised a complex and plausible plan of action. Its goal is not only to help the youth survive, but also walk with them to ensure their success.

He recognized that in order for his program to succeed and to ensure the children’s success, “he would need to select a single geographical area and devote all his energies in that one place” (4). He focused on the need for quality rather than quantity. When quality is stabilized, the quantity of students succeeding will grow naturally.

So what motivates Canada? It’s love. He would not have invested such magnitude of his time, money, and energy if I were not so.

Hope Can Make the World Go Around

Motivation is something that I find truly hard to define. We can’t truly know what motivates a person until they tell us in person. There are many elements that go into a persons’ view of the world which makes everyone unique. An example from the class would be Teresa Ashby. She works with teen moms who take advantage of her and don’t say thank you or give her enough gratitude. It is a common societal response to want to a thank you for the work that you have done. It is Teresa’s motivation that keeps her going. She shared with the class that the girls she works with are the ones that fall through the cracks and if she wasn’t there for them no one would be. She is truly an altruistic person who is a lot like Geoffrey Canada.

When analyzing a persons’ motivations it is important to look at where they come from. In the case of Canada, he can relate to the kids who are born and raised in the center of Harlem because he himself was raised there. Instead of becoming a part of the helpless cycle of poverty Canada became a successful contributor of society. One thing that Canada recognized is the programs would receive money as long as they followed the curriculum but “no one seemed to care whether the programs were actually working (p.3)” Canada took initiative and started a program that would help students from impoverished areas to succeed and learn. His program was called Promise Academy. You can tell that Canada’s motivated about what he does because of all the work and money that he put in. One example would be the extra work they did to get people from the target area (central Harlem). The outreach workers. “solicited applications from the parents of children [by] knocking on doors all over Harlem (9).”

Another motivation of Canada is that, “We’ve got to give these people a chance for hope (20).”I really do feel inspired by this quote and agree with it. It is important for a person to have hope because hope is something to keep a person always moving forward.

Monday, October 3, 2011

empathy and altruism

ok. seems that this is just not letting me copy and paste. I'll have to post this as a couple of comments, then.

Catalytic Empathy - J. Kiefer O'Sullivan

To me, Canada’s biggest motivation seems to be empathy. It is made apparent in the text that Canada lives a secure life. He has a wife and a child and is able to take care of them quite well. However, that does not stop him from feeling the pain of poverty. Not only does he want to improve the lives of the people in Harlem, but he also he also feels their struggle. In the last page of chapter 1, Canada is quoted, “’When I go home tonight to my own kid, whose life is pretty much secure’, Canada said, ‘it’s not going to make me sleep well knowing there are kids and families out there that don’t feel secure. They are just terrified that their child is not going to make it, and they think this is another opportunity that slipped by.” By having empathy for the people of Harlem, and all struggling youth, it takes the intellectual, sociological issue, and turns it into a personal one. In the eyes of Canada, all the children of Harlem, those left behind, those that are the victims of crime, etc, could be his child. To him, society’s failures are “personal failures”. From reading the text, that is what I derived as Canada’s motivation. I also believe that empathy is one of the greatest motivations you can have toward doing good in this world. The people who can empathize, the people who can see from another’s perspective, those are the ones who do the most good in the world. The people that realize that the only difference between them and someone who is poverty stricken, is a tiny shard of luck, randomly assigned in the universal lottery.

In chapter 2, several theories are laid out as to the solution to poverty, and what poor people need in order to survive. I think one of the biggest problem is that that word, “survive”, is used far too much. It should not matter what the poor of society need to survive, it should matter that they get what the rest of society already has so that they can prosper. Some people think they need moral guidelines and rules, while others think they need financial support. I think that poverty is a multi-faceted problem that requires a multi-faceted solution. I think they should be able to receive all of the above. Financial handouts are not enough, they just build dependence. Just moral support isn’t enough, as I feel it would breed resentment, for how are poor people to be blamed for what society deems bad behavior, if they do not have the basic commodities which we deem normal for society? As Canada is cited as saying, “It was almost primal, we were literally just trying to keep our children alive.” Who are we to judge the people in that society, when in most of our daily lives survival is ensured and requires not even a passing thought?

Unfortunately, most people lack empathy, and this is what leads to racism, classism, and discrimination. If more people were like Canada, the world would be a totally different place.

Why Not the Waiting List?

Geoffrey Canada seems to be motivated by a combination of the urge to create a better environment for children than the one he grew up in, and the urge to create an equal chance for every child to succeed. Canada himself grew up in an environment that might have prevented him from becoming as successful as he has, circumstances that do prevent many children from becoming successful. This environment was comparable to that of the children in the Harlem Children’s Zone before Canada put his programs in place. “In many ways, their sons and daughters were growing up the way Canada had, four decades before, just a few miles away in the South Bronx: cut off from the American mainstream, their futures constrained by substandard schools, unstable families, and a segregated city” (Tough, 3). Canada had already developed the Rheedlen programs, but was inspired, by a waiting list for one of those programs, to reevaluate his methods of assistance. “Sure, the five hundred children who were lucky enough to be participating in one of his programs were getting help, but why those five hundred and not the five hundred on the waiting list? Or why not another five hundred all together? For that matter, why five hundred and not five thousand?” (Tough, 3). One waiting list changed his perspective on helping children, from one of assistance within an existing undesirable environment, to one of eliminating that environment all together. “It was partly a gut feeling, a personal thing: he had always hated the idea of picking and choosing, helping some kids and letting the rest fail” (Tough, 5). Canada is motivated to prevent the need to choose who will receive help and who won’t, to create an environment in which all children can be successful, and to allow them all equal chances at success.

The main internal challenge that Canada seems to face is that of allowing some children to fail, while he helps other succeed. He initially encountered this issue when he took a skeptical look at the programs he placed in upper Manhattan, as part of the Rheedlen Centers for Children and Families. These were each separate programs, and Canada realized that that system wouldn’t accomplish what he was aiming for. “He believed that in troubled neighborhoods there existed a kind of tipping point. If 10 percent of the families on a block or in a housing project were engaged in one of his programs, their participation wouldn’t have much influence on their neighbors, and the children who did enroll would feel at best like special cases and at worst like oddballs. But if, say, 60 percent of the families were onboard, then participation would come to seem normal, and so would the values that went with it: a sense of responsibility, a belief that there was a point to self-improvement, a hopefulness about the future” (Tough, 5). In order to prevent the lack of cohesion responsible for the shortcomings of the Rheedlen programs, Canada developed the comprehensive Harlem Children’s Zone, believing that programs that provided the total change in environment he deemed necessary wouldn’t allow as many children to fall through the cracks.

He experiences the same dilemma when he is forced, by space constraints, to create another waiting list, this time for the Promise Charter School. “‘I was trying to get folks to leave and not to hang around to be the last kid called,’ he said. ‘This is very hard for me to see. It’s very, very sad. People are desperate to get their kids into a decent school. And they just can’t believe that it’s not going to happen.’ His eyes were watery, and as we talked he dabbed periodically at his nose with his folded-up handkerchief. ‘These parents really get it,’ he said. ‘They understand that if the school is good, the odds that your child is going to have a good life just increase exponentially” (Tough, 18-19). He was forced once again to allow some children access to the benefits he could provide, while informing some that there was no space for them. He struggles with the children that, by chance, he must refuse to help. The subject of his strongest inner struggle is unavoidable, even within such a comprehensive program as the one in place in the Harlem Children’s Zone.

My service-learning choice is Marin Country Community School. I also work at Coleman Academy, an after-school program for students below grade-level. In seeing the students in these programs, I too feel a struggle over the children who’ve fallen through the cracks. Coleman Academy is designed to prevent elementary school children from falling behind, and even to catch them up to their peers. The fact that County Community School has to exist is an indication that programs like Coleman Academy are not enough to keep children at grade level and in a healthy environment. Canada’s program creates a change in environment so drastic that it is standard for children to be helped through each stage of their lives, rather than a privilege granted to the lucky. Coleman Academy is a privilege provided to children lucky enough to participate, as the number of tutors is limited. Like Canada, the administrators of the program must make difficult choices, and wonder ‘Why these kids? And not those on the waiting list?’ Canada’s success could provide a catalyst for other regions to follow with programs as comprehensive as the Harlem Children’s Zone. In the meantime, I hope I can help those who are still on the waiting list.