Thursday, March 3, 2011

Morality: Using Emotion to Distinguish Between Right and Wrong

Morality: Using Emotion to Distinguish Between Right and Wrong

Never before had I stopped to think about the reasoning behind the actions of neither psychopaths, nor myself for that matter. I never related psychopathology to a dysfunction of the brain. However, after reading the articles from Jonah Lewer’s How We Decide I am now able to see that not all individuals are evil because they choose to be, but rather, because they have a damaged amygdala which prevents them from having any sort of emotion. This is another situation in which I’ve learned not to judge others without knowing them, I am not saying that psychopaths who commit crimes are free of guilt, but to some extent they are not in control of their actions. “Psychopaths commit violent crimes because their emotions never tell them not to” (Lewer 175). So what can be done about this? The article did not give a clear answer, but I hope that someday, a solution for psychopathic decision making can be changed.

The difference between personal and impersonal decision making was fascinating to me. The fact that personal decision making “directly involves another person” and impersonal decision making is when an individual is not directly involved, and the impact these two situations have on an individual’s actions is eye opening (177). It always seems to amaze Marin County Residents that a place like MCCS exists because it is so “hidden” in a sense from society. Or rather, is it that society refuses to accept that a place like MCCS exists in one of the richest counties in the U.S? I believe that many times people turn and look the other way because they do not want to accept what is happening in their own backyard. Children are failing, are being harmed and are not being taught to live properly; that is why they attend MCCS. This is why I love the Service-Learning program because instead of denying the problem, they made a point to tackle it and help the kids in need.

“If I look at the mass, I will never act. If I look at the one, I will” (Lewer 188). This statement had a huge impact on me because it gave me an insight as to why I continue at MCCS. I always thought that my love for helping others came from my passion to give back, and partly, because that is the way I was raised. But, it is not until now, that I fully understand my commitment to MCCS and youth around me. I had thought about this before and slightly touched upon it, but I never truly took the time to figure it out. When I think about troubled youth, my biggest drive comes from my mother. Growing up was very difficult for her because she was abused both physically and mentally and was never allowed to explore her full potential in life. I know that if my mother had some kind of guidance that she would have an entirely different life. To me she is successful because she has the biggest heart and always puts others before her, but most importantly, she never gives up. When I think back to the reading it says something to the extent that those who are abused, unconsciously abuse others; however, my mother is the exception. Never in my mothers’ life has she done to others what was done to her, on the contrary, she does the complete opposite. She helps everyone and everything, no matter what type of life they may lead. This is truly inspiring to me, and I want to be able to provide someone the help that was not given to my mother.

Many youths at MCCS live tough lives in which they have no guidance, are abused, and neglected. But, when they come to MCCS I want to show them a different side of life, one where they feel valued and see their full potential. All the students at MCCS are brilliant in their own right, they are just misguided because society has not given them the proper tools, and I want to help them gain these tools.

Sight and Blindness

I really enjoyed the statement by the chairman of GM Alfred P. Sloan, “Gentlemen. I take it we are all in complete agreement on the decision here... Then I propose we postpone further discussion of this matter until our next meeting to give ourselves time to develop disagreement and perhaps gain some understanding of what the decision is all about” (218). Good leaders, as noted with Abe Lincoln “always encouraged vigorous debate and discussion” (218), before making an important decision. Moral decisions “require taking other people into account” (175). This seems so basic and fundamental to us – what lesson do we learn in preschool when we monopolize all the building blocks? Our teachers tell us to look at Billy and see how sad he is that he has no building blocks to play with. We see the tears in Billy's eyes and we connect the moral decision – Billy is sad. Billy is sad because I have all the building blocks. Give some blocks to Billy so he will not be sad. Lehrer states “Selfishness needs to be balanced by some selflessness” (175), and I agree completely. I think our modern day world of technology and consumerism might be tipping that statement back in the other direction. The more time kids/adults spend alone in their room/office looking at their computers – fully convinced that they are “plugged-in” to the world illustrates the differences in Lehrer's personal and impersonal moral decisions. Because as he mentioned with the example of the military using new battle field tactics like when “bombs are dropped from forty thousand feet, the decision to fire is like turning the trolley wheel: people are detached from the resulting deaths” (180). This desensitization is based on the illumination of visual context. This was also demonstrated with the experiment by the eighteenth century philosopher Adam Smith, where he studied the behavior of the “ultimatum game” (182) and the change in generosity when two people are split up. When face to face, people use the 'reflective mirror' to use their own imagination to predict how the other person would feel if they were not given a fair portion of the money. Take the human closeness/contact out of the equation and our personalities and responses change. “When people play the game with computers, they are never generous” (182). I think human interaction needs to be brought back, revitalized, revamped. Written letters not e-mails are more personal and meaningful, and so too in the business world when a handshake and your word of honor used to be thought of as having more weight than a phone call.

Moral Mind/Brain is an argument

Reading about psychopaths was very scary for me. I was terrified to read, “hurting someone else is just another way of getting what he wants, a perfectly reasonable way to satisfy desires”. This statement screams out that there will be manipulation in the future. I feel for the innocent victims to come. I can have compassion for the psychopath’s previous abuse but find it difficult to reconcile the emotional damage created by a wounded amygdala.


Emotions often influence people’s decisions and we hope for the most favorable path. However, we do not always make “the right” choice. I appreciate the author of the Moral Mind’s statement of, “Morality is a series of choices about how we treat other people”. This definition of morality expresses a life long process, giving allowance for human error and realignment.


Jonah Lehrer’s explanation of how the brain works seems like a contradiction when compared to our high speed society. Although, research has shown that conflict can improve the quality of decision making and worth the effort of sorting through varying options, there is great pressure to make the right decision, quickly. The comfort of certainty undermines taking the time to analyze contradicting points of view. It also supports “top down” solutions and making justifications to protect positions.

These articles have made me more aware of the emotional range and decision making processes existing in the general public and possible characteristics to be experienced with community partners.

Teresa McCallister

"If I look at the mass, I will never act. If I look at the one, I will"

"When you talk on the phone or write an e-mail or think about someone far away, you are forced to mind read by simulation, by imagining what you would feel in the same situation." (181) I could not have said this in a more perfect way, to describe what I experienced this past Monday, with my service learning student. I had finally been matched with a student last Friday, and went to the Adult Literacy Office to obtain her records, as well as the appropriate materials I would use to begin teaching. As I drove home, I attempted to plan how and when I would call her, and what I would say. Initially I decided to contact her over the weekend when someone from her family would most likely be home, and possibly be available to help translate, since Spanish is her primary language. After thinking about it further, I felt it could be better to call her on Monday, when she would more likely be alone, and feel less self conscious about struggling to speak with a stranger. If I were in her position, that is what I would prefer. I planned my conversation, hoping I would put her at ease with simple words and questions, and called her. She answered the phone after many rings, and when I asked to speak to Roxanna, she said "Yes". After identifying myself as "the teacher from the library", I said, "I'm happy to meet you". I kept the call as short as possible; would you like to meet on Wednesday?... "Yes", can you come at 1:00?..."Yes", do you know where the library is?..."Yes", can I give you my phone number?... "Yes", do you have a pencil?..."Yes", here is my number..."Yes", Can you understand me?..."No...a little bit". "Okay, then I will see you Wednesday at 1:00 at the library unless you call me, alright?"... She said, "Yes, I'm happy to meet you"! I was overjoyed, she not only remembered the first thing I said to her, she repeated it back, sharing my enthusiasm. We spent two hours together on Wednesday, becoming acquainted as well as beginning our challenging work. Although she told me that she wants to learn EVERYTHING, one thing became clear...she wants to be able to talk to the guests at the hotel where she works, and her children's teachers. She shared how sad she felt when people at work asked her, how to get to a restaurant or a store and she could not explain or help them. She wanted my help so she in turn could help, as well as communicate with strangers. After spending time with the most cooperative, motivated, and enthusiastic student I have ever met, I have no doubt I made the right choice pursuing adult tutoring, as an internship and service learning experience. Lehrer says, "The sympathetic instinct is also one of the central motivations behind altruism, which is demonstrated when people engage in selfless acts such as donating to charity and helping out perfect strangers" (p. 183). Many strangers, that I may never meet, will eventually reap the benefits from being able to communicate with this lovely, sympathetic, "stranger", that I have the good fortune to assist.

Want for others what you want for yourself!

I am in love with Geoffrey Canada!! I applaud his tenacity and his giving heart.  This is a man who grew up in the South Bronx at a time where most of his friends were either in trouble, got wounded or died.  He could have been one of them but his grandparents moved to the suburbs and I am sure that is what helped him.  He lives the saying of ‘each one teach one’.  He researched the why’s, what and how to do something impossible and set out and is still doing it.
                I am almost done reading a book named The Warmth of Other Suns by Isabel Wilkerson.  This book tracks the Great Migration of Blacks coming out of the South into the Northern regions.  This is a great book because she interviews three people who did not know each other but they all left the South and headed to an adverturous journey of living their lives in the North – to escape their lives ending suddenly for no reason, for wanting more for themselves and their families, etc.  This book said that the people that migrated had more education, were in solid relationships (more likely to get married orstay married), less likely to become a single mother.  These people that migrated wanted their children to not have to pick cotton for twenty-two cents a day (servitude).  They did not want their children to know what Jim Crow laws were (at least not live by them). 
                In the article of Whatever It Takes by Paul Tough it mentioned how in the neighborhoods where there were once affluent people living there they would move out.  They would move out when one black family moved into the neighborhood then all of the working people would move out, the prices of the homes would fall and therefore more blacks would/could move in.  In the Warmth of Other Suns it goes into this very same thing.  Most of the black people working were working in factories or as maids, bus boys, porters, etc.  After the war the jobs became scarce (people were home from war), certain things were no longer needed because the war was over. It was hard times for all.  In the big cities (New York, Chicago, Los Angeles) where the migration had mostly settled there were pockets of neighborhoods that were all black and most people had lost their jobs (men), drugs had been introduced into the neighborhoods and also prostitution. By this time the mothers and fathers that had migrated were well into their 50’s and 60’s some of the parents back then did not speak of their lives growing up in the South because they did not want their children to have to even imagine it.
                I believe that a lot of what Geoffrey Canada is seeing is the third and fourth generation of people that were hered into the areas due to their being black.  The Warmth of Other Suns did state that Harlem and South Bronx were the areas where some of the first, second and third migrated people settled. 
                This has been an equally interesting topic for me because my grandmother came out West to get away from the South.  She never told me or her children what her life was like…she mentioned that it was hard and there was not a lot of money.  My mother was a nurse until she had a fall on the job and became handicapped.  I am in school (as we see) and I have two children, and a younger brother (in his thirties).  I have seen the children and families that are in Harlem here in California.  My brother had so many of his friends die to violence it is not funny.  My daughter has lost friends and found out due to  we were driving by and saw the body lying in the middle of the street. 
               
                This is a program that I would love to work for and support because I want to see ALL children succeed and expecially those who are from disadvantaged households.  No matter what the parents/guardians are going through they all want:  a better education for their children because they know without the proper education their children will become stuck and end up barely making it to maybe not being here to barely make it.
What is Canada’s concern is mine also.  The way he has taken a hands-on approach is due to his love of children; wanting them to get out like he did.  In the 60 minute piece as well as in the article it states that The Harlem Children’s Zone is not the first charter school with much success but it is the first that closes the gap in children pertaining to reading and math- for the first time children are equal.  Is this what Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. spoke of, is this what Malcolm X wanted for our children- to have the understanding and caring of a like-minded person the children can look up to and say ‘I want to be like him’ and can actually achieve that goal? 
                 

Wednesday, March 2, 2011

The idea of how one’s morals are based off of emotion is something that makes sense. We use our morals to do what we think is right and wrong, but what is right and wrong is different in varying situations and for each individual person. People change their morals to fit the situation they are currently in, which completely supports the idea that morals are based on emotions. “It’s only at this point-after the emotions have already made the moral decision…People come up with persuasive reasons to justify their moral intuition (173).” Many people tend to use their emotions to justify what they think is right for the situation that they are faced with at that moment. They do this without realizing what they are doing.

Decision-making is usually based off of emotions as well, which leads people to make certain decisions that reflect their morals. “At its core, moral decision-making is about sympathy. We abbor violence because we know violence hurts. We treat others fairly because we know what it feels like to be treated unfairly. We reject suffering because we can imagine what it’s like to suffer (180).” There is a reason for the actions that we all take and people expect to get something out of what they are doing. For instance, they tend to donate materialistic things instead of a helping hand. It is difficult to find a balance between giving assistance and helping. We give assistance by showing acts of kindness and learning from others in a situation, unlike doing something to help like, donating money, we don’t necessarily understand the struggle of the people who are receiving the money. We can show sympathy to those who struggle and be kind to receive the same when in need, but we should want to act kindly towards others just to do it, not to receive it in return. There are people who do things to have it returned, which is moral not justifiable to me, which shows how emotions are connected to morals.

These two articles were interesting to read and I can now make sense on how I do my decision-makings! It wasn’t surprising to read that the moral decisions we make are based on our emotions. “When you are confronted with an ethical dilemma, the unconscious automatically generates an emotional reaction”(p 173). Whenever I donate to charity, I always do it because I think of how those people must be suffering and if I were in their situation I would want someone to reach out and help me. On my first day of volunteering I discovered how good it felt to help without receiving anything in return. Lehrer is absolutely right when he states that, “ The brain is designed so that acts of charity are pleasurable; being nice to others makes us feel nice”(p 184).

I was especially surprised about the trolley hypothetical question. My first reaction to the first situation was to steer the trolley to the right. When I read the second situation, I never came up with the answer. The thought of pushing someone intentionally made me feel like a murderer, but the very thought of letting five workers died made me feel guilty. Needless to say, I am still trying to decide!

Lehrer also made some strong points on how certainty can lead to disasters. I enjoyed reading about major mistakes that can happen when leaders let their emotional side and pride get the best of them. We can always learn and grow from these examples. Our situations may not be as big as starting a war but they can cause enough trouble. Both articles state how as humans we will argue with our reasoning side to make our emotional side happy. Whether it is reasoning that incest is bad to convincing ourselves that we need the latest fashion trend, we will argue until our emotional side wins.