Monday, September 20, 2010

Larger Than Life

In finding something bigger and more universal than ourselves to care about, we discover new facets of compassion within ourselves, and a renewed "self-realization, a potentially transcendent experience of being part of a larger whole" (154). Peterson argues this approach of "embedded relationality" as a positive alternative to our current practice of ethics, in which we fail to bridge the "gap" between what we say we believe, and what we actually put into practice.

Peterson proposes that nature provides us with an avenue and an alternate reality in which to experience things that are "far larger... than [ourselves]" (155). She suggests though, that the moments we spend in this alternate reality should really become a part of, and ingrained within, our everyday and common human experiences. As much as we find nature transcendent, it too should transcend the borders of the everyday, "mundane" human experience, and become a regular part of our lives, generating "both humility and hope" (155).

The idea of living in a state of awe for something bigger and more profound than our highly individualistic and private lives is also clear in Peterson's arguments for the integration of private philosophies and ways of conducting ourselves into the public sphere. In this sense, we should be able to bring our private and personal experiences in and around nature to more public and pressing "sources of protest, criticism, and energy for political struggles" (155).

In order to achieve real results, Peterson also suggests a path of action involving practice before complete understanding, to "motivate environmental practices even without 'right intention' or full enlightenment" (132). Returning to Peterson's argument of embedded relationality, she observes that "people routinely sacrifice their apparent self-interest for those they love"(134). In keeping with this belief and practice, we should therefore be able to put the needs of the greater good above our own selfish behaviors in order to build a more just and sustainable future society. By finding common threads between what we know to be true and what we desire to be true, we should therefore in theory be able to put aside our solely private endeavors and begin "embodying the immanent utopias of everyday life" (155).


Phillipa Armes

Topsy-Turvy

Peterson argues that we are taught one language from birth, a language of “utilitarian individualism” (125).  Because we know no other method of interpreting the world, every item placed before us becomes defined in this language.  Noted repeatedly are anecdotal accounts of people who take up what could be considered environmentally “ethical” lifestyles not because an altruistic calling but rather because of personal desires. Whether this is losing weight biking, protecting lands for the next generation, or improving a sense of community, the motivating factor is indeed still inherently self-interested. “In a society so permeated by assumptions of human exceptionalism and radical individualism, it is very hard to act according to any other values” (125).  The idea is that we must break away from the constraints of our own outlook to live a position. While “intention is what makes a decision ethical or not,” it is difficult to see how intention will directly have an effect while an ethical lifestyle for the benefits it brings can have an immediate impact (127). 
Perhaps it is not necessary to develop strong self-deprivation to live a better life. Ethics must become “part not just of the responsible life but also of the ‘good life’” (126).  Returning back to our selfish environmentalists mentioned above, an ethical lifestyle can be produce through actions pleasurable and often financially beneficial. It does not feel “bad” to do things good for yourself, good for the community, or good for both. “Philosophical reflection begins with practice” rather than discovering the universe through observation, reflection, and isolated thought (130).  What could be considered ethical trial runs ultimately amount to an understanding and incorporation of values overtime. While living in Marin might encourage one through social pressures to become a vegetarian, bike to work, and hike outdoors, it is through these actions that we begin to feel good about our activities. While it is easier to watch television and sleep in late, with the original “healthy dose of determination and self-discipline” whatever the instigation may be, the more difficult and fulfilling and engaging lifestyle is likely to be adopted long term (121).
If living ethically adds much to the world without significantly detracting from what is already present, why do “we fail…to see connections among our expressed values and the practical consequences of our actions?” (117) A major difficulty is the disparity between our perceived quality of life and our actual quality of life. “Our particular dystopia may be to live in a society that undermines and even destroys what we say we value most” in that those who enjoy a certain aspect can often misplace the true value of their decisions (141). A nature lover might invest in a fishing boat to bass fish at a stocked lake rather than attending a state park to go for a hike. While the boat seems the more luxurious of the two options, the environmental and financial impact may actually create a distance between nature and the boat owner who has perceived his time outdoors as an purchased experience with a goal oriented approach.
To break out of these types of events, “people need to be able to envision better alternatives and have access to better choices” (147). By leaving the comfort zone, pushing oneself in very real ways, and taking simple steps integrated into daily life, the quality of living an ethical life in our modern day revivals if not surpasses the “normal” lifestyle. Working at the front desk in Marin AIDS Clinic has already exposed me to a new community of people. While I would have loved to have my Friday afternoons free to go hiking or finish up that last bit of lab work, the sense of being part of community and welcoming those around me was satisfying after working my first shift. I found myself talking with my trainer about what part volunteering has played in her life and the sense of purpose it lends to her every week. The conversations gave me a larger sense of connection than reading the newspaper or following the work of organizations also working on AIDS across the world. While not my “normal” lifestyle, I did not feel it detracted from my day even with the time given up.
Circe McDonald

Saturday, September 18, 2010

Last Chapters in Everyday Ethics

In these final chapters, Peterson goes deeper into what she perceives as different sources/motivations/ways of perceiving and being in the world that both build capacity for and manifest the "practice-based ethics" that she is advocating. She delineates many of the ways in which our current way of thinking/teaching ethics falls short when it comes to actually informing our behavior and writes movingly about alternative ways of thinking about ourselves in relation to others and to the earth. She writes:

"We live by a collective ethic when we experience ourselves not as voluntaristic, self-sufficient monads but as social creatures enmeshed in and joyfully dependent upon a web of relationships and practices over which we do not have ultimate control" (150).


I would add that although we can not "control" this larger reality, our actions do shape it--that is the point of ethics and what she is driving at.

Unpack at least one of Peterson's arguments about the need for this alternative ethic or some of the ways in which we can better develop and act on this approach. Use your service-learning experience to illustrate your points, when/if possible.

Tuesday, September 7, 2010

Scale

In our most recent reading, I found one particular idea to be the most intriguing, the scale of how life is perceived and carried out. Peterson often references the individual versus the community as well as personal versus social. Two specific examples of this idea are the family unit and the concept of a utopia. In both instances, Peterson discusses smaller scale happenings and how they are, or can be, carried out in the world on a larger scale.
Referencing interracial marriages, Peterson writes, "...these relationships provide both a seed and a model of a better world: they build it here and now while also pointing toward future possibilities" (Peterson 42). The complex social, political, and economic structures within marriage have a strong influence outside of the personal realm. A good marriage that emphasizes equality, acceptance, and caring will, in turn, promote these aspects in the world at large. However, marriages based on a patriarchal structure, or other negative traditions, only work to continue negative social occurrences.
Peterson says, "...the utopian moments of private life help give rise to and sustain public commitments" (22). Although a true utopian society seems impossible in the natural world, instances of utopian perfection can be found through some personal relations. If only the experience of the relationship with one, true good friend could be magnified to an entire community then a utopia could possibly exist. However, just as every marriage cannot be perfect, human interactions are often unpleasant.
Peterson presents many relevant concepts of scale in her book that hold especially true for us in the modern day. Technology often pushes communities farther apart, perhaps making our generation more focused than ever on individual relationships. Now, it is important to reapply the positive aspects of our personal lives and relationships back into the world.

Monday, September 6, 2010

Connecting Community with Self

To introduce the idea that the spheres of personal and public life are connected, Peterson discusses political activists in El Salvador and Nicaragua who possibly risk their lives for public causes, but are motivated to do so for their loved ones. One example was women who become activists after their husbands are killed. They think, “I had to continue what my husband did, and not just because he was my husband…he was humble and affectionate with the children, the communities, I saw I had to continue doing what he was doing when they killed him.” The women didn’t become activists to avenge their husband’s deaths. Conversely, they were inspired by the high moral code their husbands lived by and emulated them by continuing their work.

I grew up in Minnesota and attended public schools in Minneapolis for my entire education. My mom taught at the elementary school I attended. Trust me, it wasn’t always the prettiest picture. A lot of the kids came from broken homes and had little economic opportunity. I remember driving home from school with my mom and she said; “your dad and I try to give you every opportunity we possibly can, but a lot of your classmates don’t have parents to do that, so I do everything I can to help them, and you should too.” My mom constantly connected her private life to her public one by coming home and teaching my sister and I how to help others. She also brought her private life into her public one, simply because my sister and I attended the school where she worked.

Almost on accident, we want to emulate people we love and care for in our private life. If someone you care about does great things, you will want to do great things for the world, thus connecting the spheres of private and public. Because my mom constantly strived to help underprivileged kids, I in turn wanted to lend a hand to others.

It seems fairly obvious why service learning and ethics are connected. Ethics are all about different people’s moral codes. What would be a better way to develop your own moral codes than to see how others struggle and finding ways to help them?

Expanding and Strengthening the Utopia

     From the beginning pages, Anna L. Peterson contrasts our massive struggles, “it’s hard to look at the world outside and not find reasons for discouragement and motivation to retreat,” and the hope to overcome these found in human’s “utopias of everyday life.” (1, 5) Utopia is not only within our grasp but has been found in minor ways at various points in each individual’s life. Peterson finds “utopia” occurring within small interactions, particularly healthy marriages and friendships where peace, caring, and equality are displayed. These concepts aren’t somehow above and beyond human nature. For example, through our individual experiences we all have “the relations of love and solidarity, even if these are fragile and fragmentary” (2). If love and solidarity are necessary foundations of a utopian society, the next steps would be to figure out how to capture and cultivate these ideas. With outside financial, social, emotional, and environmental pressures, how can morality be maintained or even extended beyond these brief moments in protected settings? Since we obtain “living ethics” in short periods and certain relationships, the solution must lay in how we can transfer these ideas into a larger and more robust state. Extending beyond ourselves into a stronger, collective network of empathy will result in the building of social movements and the creation of new frameworks of ethical behavior redefining the interactions between individuals and eventually society.


     Yet, major obstacles stand in the way of this development. “[The] utilitarian, contractual perspective defines the good life in terms only of individual choice, preference, and personal satisfaction, without binding commitments or substantive shared values” creating blinders and limiting our understanding not only of others in society but also the nature of society, lending the impression that as individuals we are passive in the formation and future of our community and each broader layer from there all the way our planet (13). In a society heavily based on individualism and logic, defining what people, animals, and the environment means in context of ethics is difficult at best in most cases. What does the plight of migrant farmer workers, or any other non-self group, mean in ethical and emotional terms rather than social, economic, and political facets? Since the idea of the good life becomes about the individual, it is harder to look upon others as an element of a self-network.

     By looking out upon the world in utilitarian ways, it becomes a sacrifice and restraint to act ethically rather than a natural byproduct of being interconnected to those around us. Retreating back to protective settings weakens and shortens our social gains on the large scale even when small individual advances are made. Shying away from extended empathy attempts to create a short term barrier to protect us from much of the civic responsibility each of us bares in the matter, a shield from the world in which we can care for fragile ethics away from violence and instability. “We are all inside a cell, insofar as we have some small, limited space in which we can enact qualities that do not seem possible outside-equality, kindness, unself-interested love” (21). Yet, living and cultivating ourselves in the cell, the walls became gradually strengthened, at least in our perceptions of them, until the cell becomes accepted, incorporated, and looked upon as a positive respite from struggle. Marriage becomes “seen as a sanctuary for pleasures and values that cannot survive the public sphere” and friendships “decenter the self” removing us from intense responsibility while urging us to become equal and connected to those around us, though only in immediate relationships (39, 35). 

Peterson believes that “we need to distinguish more clearly between the obstacles that are existential and ineradicable and those that are socially imposed and open to transformation” (5). If the restriction and separation of the implementation of ethics in public and private spheres are only perceived, finding ways to better understand our interactions with the world should help alleviate the problem. One way to escape the cycle of retreat to marriage and friendship, which separates societal development and self development, is to amass experiences and interpersonal understandings to the point at which our connections extend beyond marriage and increase the range of our friendship, which can be aided by Service Learning as well as other actions which move us away from our normal social groups and interactions. Extending understanding removes the perception that our love is held within a fixed space allowing us to shift our understanding of how unchangeable the world is. Changing our perceptions of the world can help separate, question, and define barriers.

A large social network and understanding extends our empathy far beyond the individual in a very real way. It is easier to care about more people when there are more people around who have earned and gained your emotional attachments. Service learning is a step marking the transition from “good ideas” to “good practices and experiences (25). To start using practices means that they can develop naturally like any other social trend or technology as can our understanding of the problems involved in implementing our ethics outside our personal networks. Rather than waiting to have the best ideas to change the world, we can start immediately with little trends which would result in the small betterment of daily life while increasing our understanding. Each of these small steps can collectively create a change in community when started in individual relationships and then expanded outward into eventually overlapping circles and strong bonds.

Circe McDonald

Let All That You Do Be Done In Love

We, as inheritors of the 21st Century Western world, know a great deal about freedom. We have guaranteed rights and liberties which our outlined in the American Constitution and socially accepted partitions from encroaching on the rights and liberties of others; we mature at a much slower pace than generations prior, and yet we understand the concept of individual choice like no generation before. Growing up in Marin County and starting college at 17 years old, I can say that I have been a witness to our generation's enthusiasm for individuality and ever increasing methods of liberation from authority while straining at the margins of socially acceptable behavior.

However, as a child growing up in a tight knight Sonoma County community, I understood the need for congregation and fellowship more than the need to self satisfy, and in my adulthood I have wrestled with the duality of private interests and public connectedness. In the book Everyday Ethics and Social Change, Anna L. Peterson proposes that our ethical foundation as a society should be rooted firmly in the interconnectedness of the private and public sectors. We have love for individual relationships and desires; however this love should not deminish our capacity to connect to larger institutional frameworks (such as neighborhoods, citys, and policical localities) but strengthen our commitment to them for the preservation of our private and public life. As Peterson states, "love is both a human emotion and a political principle” (p. 22). Our overall sense of community should allow us to understand "first, the link between ‘politics’ and [our] real lives, and second, the bonds between people who face similar problems and seek similar goods” (p. 12).

It is then also important to understand that the way we love our communities must be a reflection of the way we love in our individual relationships. Love is not just an action that we can show towards our parents or friends, but a way for us to value the framework of a society that allows us to prosper in our personal relationships. It is a way of saying thank you to the world which has allowed us to grow as individuals, of telling the communities that fostered our growth "I appreciate you"; in short, every day should be Community Day.

I propose that we view ourselves not only as those who inherit the order, but those who have been entrusted with its future. If “the community is held together by ...‘examples of the men and women who have embodied and exemplified the meaning of community’”, then our purpose in this service learning course is not only to log hours and make relationships within the framework of a local organization, but to use our experiences this fall as an example for those that will inherit this community after us (p. 7). With the same care and love that we dedicate to our activities, our classes, and our camus social network we should dedicate to this community, who by simply existing has allowed for the creation of a Dominican University of California and seen that we, as Honors students, will graduate with an understanding of what it means to love something bigger than ourselves.

Jessica Fraser