Monday, September 20, 2010

Topsy-Turvy

Peterson argues that we are taught one language from birth, a language of “utilitarian individualism” (125).  Because we know no other method of interpreting the world, every item placed before us becomes defined in this language.  Noted repeatedly are anecdotal accounts of people who take up what could be considered environmentally “ethical” lifestyles not because an altruistic calling but rather because of personal desires. Whether this is losing weight biking, protecting lands for the next generation, or improving a sense of community, the motivating factor is indeed still inherently self-interested. “In a society so permeated by assumptions of human exceptionalism and radical individualism, it is very hard to act according to any other values” (125).  The idea is that we must break away from the constraints of our own outlook to live a position. While “intention is what makes a decision ethical or not,” it is difficult to see how intention will directly have an effect while an ethical lifestyle for the benefits it brings can have an immediate impact (127). 
Perhaps it is not necessary to develop strong self-deprivation to live a better life. Ethics must become “part not just of the responsible life but also of the ‘good life’” (126).  Returning back to our selfish environmentalists mentioned above, an ethical lifestyle can be produce through actions pleasurable and often financially beneficial. It does not feel “bad” to do things good for yourself, good for the community, or good for both. “Philosophical reflection begins with practice” rather than discovering the universe through observation, reflection, and isolated thought (130).  What could be considered ethical trial runs ultimately amount to an understanding and incorporation of values overtime. While living in Marin might encourage one through social pressures to become a vegetarian, bike to work, and hike outdoors, it is through these actions that we begin to feel good about our activities. While it is easier to watch television and sleep in late, with the original “healthy dose of determination and self-discipline” whatever the instigation may be, the more difficult and fulfilling and engaging lifestyle is likely to be adopted long term (121).
If living ethically adds much to the world without significantly detracting from what is already present, why do “we fail…to see connections among our expressed values and the practical consequences of our actions?” (117) A major difficulty is the disparity between our perceived quality of life and our actual quality of life. “Our particular dystopia may be to live in a society that undermines and even destroys what we say we value most” in that those who enjoy a certain aspect can often misplace the true value of their decisions (141). A nature lover might invest in a fishing boat to bass fish at a stocked lake rather than attending a state park to go for a hike. While the boat seems the more luxurious of the two options, the environmental and financial impact may actually create a distance between nature and the boat owner who has perceived his time outdoors as an purchased experience with a goal oriented approach.
To break out of these types of events, “people need to be able to envision better alternatives and have access to better choices” (147). By leaving the comfort zone, pushing oneself in very real ways, and taking simple steps integrated into daily life, the quality of living an ethical life in our modern day revivals if not surpasses the “normal” lifestyle. Working at the front desk in Marin AIDS Clinic has already exposed me to a new community of people. While I would have loved to have my Friday afternoons free to go hiking or finish up that last bit of lab work, the sense of being part of community and welcoming those around me was satisfying after working my first shift. I found myself talking with my trainer about what part volunteering has played in her life and the sense of purpose it lends to her every week. The conversations gave me a larger sense of connection than reading the newspaper or following the work of organizations also working on AIDS across the world. While not my “normal” lifestyle, I did not feel it detracted from my day even with the time given up.
Circe McDonald

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.