Like a tree heavy with fruit, some of which is overripe, some of which is not ready to be picked, and some of which is diseased and pitted with parasites, there are maybe one or two pieces of fruit which are just right for eating. As I harvest the bounty from this tree, it is difficult for me to tell which of the fruit is just right, because from the outside they look just the same as those that aren't ready to be picked, or those that should have been picked long ago, or those whose flesh hosts unwelcome guests.
And so it is for me as I try to wade through the various theories and ideas of what it means to be authentic. In Julia's prompt, she asks that we not make judgments until we actually understand the points that the writers are making. I understand and appreciate this expectation, but how do I know whether or not I understand their logic? I don't. At times, I might think I do, but I would bet you that I don't.
I confess that I have refrained from posting on this blog until now because I have felt stymied. But I've decided that I need to do what is right for me (authentic? maybe so) and dive right in regardless of whether I am confident in my abilities to understand the concepts in this week's writings. So here goes—and
I hope you will forgive me if I completely miss the point!
After reading Taylor, Guignon, and Porter, my take is that there are no right answers to the question of what it means to be authentic; however, there appear to be plenty of wrong answers. And some of the answers, right or wrong, are almost circular in that they seem to go around and around an idea but not through its heart. Maybe, though, that is the nature of philosophical writing. And the more I read about being authentic, the more I wonder just how important it is. Well, now that I see that in black and white, that statement seems silly—of course it is important to be authentic! It's just that it seems like these writers are making it more complicated and confusing than necessary.
Last week, when I was reading Taylor, an impression I noted was that a personal mission statement—something like corporations and school districts and other entities use to define their goals and intentions—might be necessary to be an authentic human being. But then that also seems kind of silly. After all, I know me, I know what interests me, I know what expectations I have for myself and others, and I know my faults. If I intrinsically know these things, why is it necessary to spell them out?
Maybe I'm not explaining this well. I guess it is that some of what these writers espouse seems so clearly manmade and somewhat artificial (surely the antithesis of being authentic) and are therefore off-putting. Should we look within to find the answers? Well, yes, but don't forget to think about society. If the answers are within me and I find them, and if I remember to include society in my mission, will I be an authentic human being? Maybe, but probably not. But then, if the answers really are within me, don't I run the risk of being selfish and self-centered? Yes. And if the answers are within me, why would it matter how someone else defines being authentic, because wouldn't that person's definition be centered on his/her own beliefs? And if I decided that following my own common sense and trying to live the Golden Rule weren't authentic and instead tried to follow someone else's definition, how authentic could that be? And in doing that, wouldn't I lose the essence of me?
Fairly early in On Being Authentic, Guignon writes, "The ideal of authenticity has two components. …get in touch with the real self we have within…through introspection, self-reflection or mediations…express that unique constellation of inner traits in our actions in the external world—to actually be what we are…in our relationships, careers, and practical activities" (6). This would seem to support my personal definition of being authentic, but I have a niggling feeling that I am missing his point. And, to paraphrase Gertrude Stein, what if when we listen to ourselves there is no there there? Guignon, too, writes, "What if it turns out that this true self includes some fairly nasty—or even worse, banal—characteristics, traits we would prefer not to think of as really us…and…are actually products of the latest fads and fancies…" (9).
"For many people, the quest for authenticity has turned out to be a setup for disappointment and failure…'they must not be doing it right'" (8). Guignon also notes the possible pitfalls of self-help programs, "…many people…end up feeling frustrated and defeated, unable to understand why such a good program of self-improvement turned out to be so disappointing" (x). But then, Guignon also skewers some of my own philosophy—at least some of which is mentioned in the previous two paragraphs (finding the answers within me and following the Golden Rule)—he writes that what is lost includes, "…the notion of an authoritative source of direction and insight I can turn to in order to learn how I should live my life. For when my guide is understood as nothing other than me, it is hard to see what authority this guidance could or should have" (xii). That seems rather paternalistic to me. As humans, we are blessed with brains that are individual and creative and reflective; why can't we be our own authorities? I don’t think life, or authenticity, is like an algebraic equation where variables (our goals and ideas) can only be solved in one way with a theorem or formula.
If self-help gurus "…have an effect of pressuring people into thinking in ways that confirm the ideology of the founders of the program…" (9), how is this different than following what Guignon has to say? Now, I might be the only person in the U.S. who has never seen an Oprah show or Dr. Phil, and I have never followed (at least, I don't think I have) a self-help program, but I do think that whatever means that might help someone live a happier, more fulfilling life is wonderful. However, since it appears that Guignon may be opposed to the self-help movement, what is he doing, then, writing about authenticity? Or is his view that learning to be authentic is fine for philosophers but not for regular people? Couldn't his book be defined—if one is bent on always defining something—as a self-help book? And isn't "self-help" just a label, just as "being authentic" is too? (I'm giving myself a headache.)
If I am a doer and am reflective and consider others, does that make me authentic? Or am I just occasionally authentic—like a tourist? Do I need to have a place in the scheme of things as Guignon notes that a Platonic reading of Socrates would suggest? I don't think so.
I will be interested to see where Guignon takes his thoughts in future chapters. Right now in the book, stuck in premodern times, with ancient rites and rituals, the biblical narrative structure (more circular thinking), it would seem that there are no right answers. But then, maybe we don't need the answers from outside sources; maybe all the answers we need are within us.