Thursday, February 4, 2010

Response and thoughts

The charismatic leader needs to know that finally he was not created by God." p.111

There's an old story (perhaps it is now a Myth) about a Roman general that returned victorious from a great battle. Cezar assigned a slave to ride in the chariot with this general as he triumphantly paraded through the streets of Rome. The slave was required to whisper in the ear of the general "You are only mortal, you are not a God" as the crowds cheered wildly for him. I believe that it is too easy to slip into believing the words of others, especially when they are positive words. But the same holds true for society as a whole. We when are told that problems are too big to overcome - or that they will take a lot of work - we often shy away from the problem in persuit of something else instead of simply making a beginning. For if we make a beginning, perhaps others will see and want to help as well. But even if we fail, we can still have the experience - one which will give us more lessons about things that we can't even imagine yet.

Here were my thoughts on the questions posed in the sylabus. They also tie in with the beginning of our selected reading by Myles Horton and Paulo Freire:

“Without practice there is no knowledge.”
- We Make the Road by Walking: Myles Horton and Paulo Freire
I know what a Unicorn looks like – even though I have never had the experience of meeting one in real life. I know how fission works, although I will never be able to actually see it happen (for it is too small and happens too fast for me to be able to witness with my own eyes). But in other ways – love, tolerance, mechanical skills – I cannot know these things until I have experienced them. Love is a fine thought, a nice idea – and that is all it will be until it is experienced. Then it is discovered that it is an amazing and wonderful (sometimes overpowering) experience that changes lives. If Plato’s Socrates is right, then without love inside of the individual, it is impossible to expect love from society. As such, political justice and knowledge must come from the experience had by the individuals – which makes up the collective knowledge.
And yet, we all know what a Unicorn is. Is it possible for us to have certain ideas that are outside of our own experience? Where do these ideas come from? Why are you, me, and others able to envision such a creature? Through education – we have been taught what it is. Someone else has given us the theory that is necessary for us to begin. We change through the teachings of others. However, if it is simply given to us, such knowledge becomes cheapened – we must struggle for it or it has little meaning. As such, we learned what a Unicorn was for a purpose (more than likely one that we can no longer recall) and that knowledge did not stick. However, the Unicorn concept did – because we had to struggle for it.
So then, all change comes from struggle. We had to struggle to wrap our heads around the idea of a Unicorn – and as such it took on meaning. We took action. And action is what is required if we are to change ourselves in other ways – ways that allow us to become better people. For we must become better people if we are to attempt to make the world a better place. Good intentions are all well and good, but they have no purpose or way of implementation if we have not had the experience of changing ourselves and gaining in the skills necessary to affect others and the world as a whole.
So we initially struggled to imagine what the unicorn is. We learned how, through struggle, to bring into existence in our minds something that has yet to be. We practiced for the most important task which will happen later – to imagine ourselves as better persons. For if we cannot imagine what a unicorn looks like, how can we ever hope to imagine how we can be better? We must take the lessons learned from theory into practice. Through this practice we have learned the path. And now, having had the practice needed, we can, indeed, make ourselves into the ones that we want to be, and all because we once learned how to imagine a Unicorn.

1 comment:

  1. Yes, well said--theory is important and Freire and Horton definitely talk about this--your interpretation is well articulated. I'm not so sure that the concept of the unicorn completely works to unpack this (is the unicorn a theory?) but it works, for me, on a different level. It makes me think about the role of imagination and the ways in which the ability to imagine/conjure is such an important aspect of our humanity. Imagining is different than theory--sometimes more fun! But it can, as you note, serve a similar purpose--it gives us something to work towards, a way to see what the world could look like if we could expand and grow and relate to others in positive ways. Maybe the unicorn stands for that kind of possibility to you. We all have our unicorns and like that abstract idea of love--when we experience or glimpse it, no matter how briefly, we are inspired. The moral imagination is a huge resource for our humanity to be sure.

    ReplyDelete

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.