Sunday, February 28, 2010

Prompt for On Kindness

In a sense, this is more than a prompt, it is also a bit of a reading guide to help you, hopefully, get to the crux of the ideas presented here--try not to react to the premise of these ideas but to reflect on the philosophical implications.

1. Against Kindness

The authors' thesis (you may not agree but try to see this on a societal level, not from your individual perspective) is that, “[m]ost people appear to believe that deep down they (and other people) are mad, bad, and dangerous to know. . . our motives are utterly self-seeking, and that our sympathies are forms of self-protection” (4).

The authors suggest that although many of us live the kind life in “instinctive sympathetic identification with the vulnerabilities and attractions of others. . . but without a language in which to express this, or cultural support for it” (4)

(Again, remember, at times we have to over-generalize in order to be able to examine collective issues, and if we look at the state of our own country in the moment, there may be some evidence that supports these claims.)

One of the reasons, that the authors suggest, for our ambivalence about our instinct for kindness, has to do with our own vulnerability, not wanting to experience our own weaknesses: “Bearing other people’s vulnerability—which means sharing in it imaginatively and practically . . .––entails being able to bear one’s own” (11). In a sense, what we have in common is our vulnerability (an idea that Judith Butler will elaborate on in Precarious Life).

Thus, kindness has an internal tension—it brings us pleasure but it also reminds us of all that we fear about ourselves including change. (There is also an interesting discussion about whether kindness requires selflessness—hopefully we will discuss in class as this is important and a theme that will come up in C. Fred Alford’s book on whistleblowers.)

Think about these ideas in relationship to your service. Can you illustrate through an experience that you have had already or in relation to your own process of starting this commitment? Use other parts of the reading to make more connections and elaborate. Such as:

2. A Short History of Kindness

(To continue the discussion of selflessness vs selfishness) Two Enlightenment views of kindness: “For most of pre-modern history . . . kindness was seen as a solution to a problem: the problem of other people”(27). Kindness was seen as a bridge between separate entities in which the motive was more about surviving as an individual. The alternative view did not see people as separate entities but as interconnected (28). The authors illustrate this view with Adam Smith’s philosophy of “fellow feeling” and “imaginative projection of self into other” (29).

Continue to probe and unpack these ideas and use other parts of the history to explore and connect these ideas. If we are interdependent, is it selfish to be kind? And if we are interdependent, is it possible to be selfless? Maybe you can connect to your ideas above about your service experience.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.