Thursday, February 4, 2010

One concept that I have grappled with in our readings relates directly to the pervading themes of theory and practice and one’s individual moral calling. In particular, it is that which Myles Horton refers to in We Make the Road by Walking when speaking of “being neutral” vs. “choosing a side” in a cause. It is a difficult concept for me because in the way Horton explains it, “neutrality has nothing to do with anything but agreeing with what is and what will always be” (102). Yet, for me personally, I have seen neutrality as an important learning place before accepting ideas and choosing sides wholeheartedly. At the same time, however, I think I may understand where Horton is coming from and I feel I can find agreement.

In part, this is tough because Horton is speaking from the standpoint of an educator. Yet, what he says, at least at first, seems to go against what I have recently learned in my education with the Humanities. That is, the practice of taking concepts inch by inch, and only accepting those pieces that, through careful scrutiny, prove to be consistently true and beneficial. To me, this has everything to do with not choosing the wrong side. It has everything to do with being critical. It is all about a steadfast nonconformity with that which does not work.

On another level, I see how Horton is also speaking from the standpoint of an experienced social activist. Through this perspective, I can see how the status of “neutrality” and conceptual criticism change immensely. As Horton says, “You need to know why you take sides; you should be able to justify it,” and when it comes to human rights, this becomes much easier to do and the process of deliberation becomes much less important (102).

On these matters of conceptual criticism and one’s involvement in a cause, it was Paulo Freire that really broke it down for me. He said that “the question is not just to make the criticism but to interpret the dreams of the people… [O]ne is much more of a translator of the aspirations and dreams of the people, instead of being the creator of the dreams” (111,112). Hence, it is not about trying to create your own right answer and worrying about being on the right side. Once you understand the dreams of the people, neutrality is useless, the criticism is much less important, and action for those dreams is crucial.

1 comment:

  1. Yes, you make a good point, Walker and I think that this may be a matter of semantics more than anything. Remaining open to multiple viewpoints in order to expand and grow in our education and in our lives is not really the neutralty that Freire and Horton are talking about which is a neutrality in the face of real suffering, or ideas and theories that may lead to suffering. Their point is that when you remain neutral instead of taking a stand when you on in a position to take a stand, then you ARE actually taking the side of the oppressor. This is different than being engaged in thought and ideas that open us to different realities. This is what a humanities education is all about--preparing us to act not REACT--meaning to take action based on criticical and creative thinking that is based on having listened to many voices and viewpoints. If we don't ever take a stand and act, then the value of that education is kind of limited to our own sense of very personal fulfillment and what we can contribute as objective by-standers. And even then, can we ever really claim to have an objective stance? Our "objectivity" is always filtered through our own experiences, our own conditioning, our own narrative. I'm glad that you raised this point because it is a really good one to think about.

    ReplyDelete

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.