Thursday, February 18, 2010

The Elephant and the Rider

In the Happiness Hypothesis, the author describes a theory that was developed over time. That theory was to think of the mind and self as an elephant and a rider. The elephant is our base emotional responses and feelings. The rider is our rational mind. We struggle with these two forces inside of us constantly. The rational mind sees what is best, but we often are controlled by the elephant - which leads us the opposite way.

The author's theory is a metaphor for human nature - the several different aspects of ourselves that must be reconciled in order for us to truly become a full person. This struggle never truly ends, and it - in many ways - is what truly defines us. Logic verse emotion, rational verse feeling body verse mind - these are the constant battles within us.

This may be all well and good for a person with a scientific view of the world, but I believe that it leaves out a critical part of the equation: the spiritual. There is no mention of a force outside of ourselves that can, in any way, influence us. This, I feel, is essential to the struggle. After all, if there is no outside force creating situations, then there is no need for either the elephant or the rider. Also, if there is no spirituality, there is no way to short cercuit the entire process and allow us to see outside of ourselves from time to time.

However, my thoughts and opinions are not of importance here. What is important is the author's views - which seem to be this: We have a rational way of thinking, we have emotions. These come into conflict - the only way that we can progress through life is by allowing this conflict, recognizing it for what it is, finding a way to harmonize the two dissident sides, and grow. Marvellous.

1 comment:

  1. You're very right. He doesn't touch on spirituality at all--at least not as a force that comes from outside. I think that this is because he has a different focus in this chapter--yet, I do agree with you Ken, that the metaphor feels a bit limited. I think it works to help us thing about ourselves and our internal functioning but not so much about the reality of the living that comes out of this relationship between rider and elephant and the other dimensions of our existence which don't really fit in this metaphor.

    ReplyDelete

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.