Wednesday, January 27, 2010

Marty Dunn blogging in.... any question yet?

1 comment:

  1. Hi Everybody. I can strongly identify with various positions of researchers mentioned in this article who tried to answer the question, "why are poor people poor?" Here’s why: I am one of 5 children who lived in poverty at various points in my childhood after my parents divorced. I know what it's like to be poor--when, in the 3rd wk of a month and the food stamps run out and the fridge is empty. I am absolutely certain that my mother would not have hesitated for a heartbeat to go shop at Walmart that week of the month. This experience came to mind when our discussion last week turned into a debate about the righteousness of where you shop for food. There are grey areas about ethical conduct and I try to allow myself the flexibility to put the situation into context of immediate vs. longterm priorities. My mother's 1st priority was to not let her children go hungry. I'm sure she would have resumed shopping elsewhere when the food stamps were replenished. The reading had me comparing my family’s predicament to some of the assumptions: 1) if Mr. Charles Murray had his way, and AFDC (food stamps, etc) were not available to families like mine, we would have gone hungry or my mother would have descended to more desperate measures to feed us. Fortunately, AFDC helped us during that temporary period of poverty. His position that people are poor "because the government helps too much," while initially it had me shaking my head, it made a little sense when I considered that because the food stamps were not even enough to really feed 5 children & 1 adult, perhaps that's why my mother was so keen on getting off welfare ASAP. It wasn't easy and it wasn't enough; 2) the article's concluding pages synthesize research that eventually came around to the idea that people need skills to get themselves out of poverty, and you don't need to be an Einstein to do well in life (if you have the work ethic, which for some of us springs from a desire not to be dependent on welfare handouts and suffer the corresponding demoralization of not being able to care for yourself) and skills! I was a high school dropout and found myself labeled an "at risk youth." I was very fortunate to have had access to good job training program. When I had barely turned 16 I found myself working full time and going to school one night a week to study for the High School Equivalency Exam. Not only did that intervention help me get a HS certificate, it helped me get into the job market. My first work mates were gang bangers fresh out of the Watsonville Juevenile Hall. My only crime was poverty and family instability--one of the factors identified by the researchers. That experience also helped me to understand how much more advantaged I was (despite being equally as poor as my workmates) just by the mere fact that I was white and raised by fairly well-educated parents. My speech was free of slang and accent. My color was right for being interviewed by white potential employers. I could hide my background of poverty merely with my ability to be well-spoken. So the assumptions by the researchers about family and neighborhood influence feels right on the money with me. I never lived in a pure ghetto with high percentages of people living below the poverty line. We moved a lot (I went to 12 different schools between K and 8th grade) but we never landed in a pure ghetto, so I am in agreement with that assessment that socio-economic diversity of neighborhoods is a good thing of you're poor and will probably help you not fall into the generational cycle of poverty norm of life in those extreme high poverty ghetto neighborhoods. So, how did the reading strike the rest of you?

    ReplyDelete

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.