Saturday, February 26, 2011
Prompt: The Moral Mind and The Brain is an Argument
and/or
In the next chapter, "The Brain is an Argument." Lehrer talks about the importance of doubt and the inner dialogue in making decisions and judgments. He writes that although confidence is comforting, the "desire to always be right is a dangerous side-effect of having competing regions inside one's head" (210). As Lehrer illuminates through a variety of stories, feeling sure and acting on certain assumptions can create a dangerous sense of false security. Again, what interests you most here? Why? Can you link to your service experience?
Thursday, February 24, 2011
Canada in America!
Whatever It Takes
The life changing work Geoffrey Canada has begun in Harlem is ambitious, daunting, and extremely powerful. In my last blog post I asked the question, “Why don't more people with money give back to those less fortunate?” and Canada is my answer. Here is a man who grew up in the streets of Harlem, and saw first hand the problems associated with a life of poverty: increased addiction to drugs and alcohol, theft, domestic abuse and child neglect, gang violence and the ever-present reality of death. “It really is getting worse. Too many guns, too much crack, too few jobs, so little hope” (1). Canada is an exception to the norm. He made it out of that lifestyle and now wants to show the way for others. By creating the Promise Academy Charter School within a protected 'safe' zone called the Harlem Children's Zone, Canada takes those from low income families chosen by lottery under his wing. He stays with each child/family from Kindergarden through high school. “The support system he provided would need to be comprehensive, a continuous linked series of programs. It wasn't enough to help out in just one part of a child's life: the project would need to combine educational, social, and medical services” (Tough, 4). And the most extraordinary thing is his guarantee that all students will attend college. If this isn't ambitious enough, he foots the bill for their education. In addition to the children benefitting from the program, the parents are educated as well. They are taught parenting skills which range from diapers to finances. The ultimate goal is to help raise a community out of the depths of poverty, drugs, and violence, and into a community of hope and possibility.
However you measure parenting, middle-class parents tend to do it very differently from poor parents – and the path they follow, in turn, tends to give their children an array of advantages, both cognitive and non-cognitive: a bigger vocabulary, better brain chemistry, a more assertive attitude. As Lareau pointed out, kids from poor families might be nicer, they might be happier, they might be more polite – but in countless ways, the manner in which they are raised puts them at a disadvantage in the measures that count in contemporary American society (16).
Canada's 60 Minutes interview was enthralling. His passion was evident, as was his ultimate dream. Communities across the nation would change dramatically if there were more Promise Academies. Statistics showed that the cost of student education was less than the cost of housing them in jail. Getting adolescents and teenagers off the streets and away from crime and violence will strengthen not hurt our economy. Canada's methods are different, but effective. One in particular is his love for bribing students. If students maintain a certain GPA then at the end of the semester they are given a check. This has caused students to become more committed, time efficient, responsible, and excited about their education. The personal vision of one man has changed the lives of many. This acknowledgement helps me to see that America's future might be a little brighter. We are capable of so many things: exploring the depths of the ocean and sending someone to the moon, landing rovers on Mars, crashing satellites into asteroids, nano-technologies, medical breakthroughs... all this is being accomplished by a small fraction of our society, the middle and upper-class. But as Canada has proved, the neglected or 'counted out' if given the same educational opportunities can perform and contribute just as much to society. Geoffrey Canada is a modern day messiah, and his message is the most fundamental – give everyone a chance to live, dream, and succeed by ending the “decades – generations – of discrimination, isolation, and cultural decay” (6).
Whatever it Takes: Geoffrey Canada's Quest to Change Harlem and America is addition to my knowledge of Canada’s successful change to education in Harlem. When reading about Canada a smile always appears on my face because he is so driven to see his plan unfold to its fullest capacity, and make sure each individual child was prepared for college. Another aspect that I like about Canada is he never stops believing in a child after high school, he continues to help motivate them even during college. For many people they view Canada as an egotistic man who is ill preparing the students and is only doing this for himself. If you look at his situation realistically, he is going beyond what local public schools should be doing. We as people cannot fault him because a select few can attend his school. The fingers should be pointed and the government for not given children their rights to a better education. I appreciate Canada for selecting “a single geographical area and devote all of his energies to that one place.”
Comparing the reading to my service learning is simple. MAP is a community of its own that makes sure that everyone that walks through their doors is helped to the best of their ability. No one at MAP gets turned away, but similar to Promise Academy, MAP’s services are not for everyone. As I mentioned before MAP helps everyone, if they cannot service someone they recommend other facilities that will better suit the client. Promise Academy is not like any other charter school and I can compare it to MAP because it is not like your local Planned Parenthood.
Recently MAP opened my eyes and showed me how they truly care for every client. As mentioned in the reading Canada intervened in children’s lives and MAP follows suit. MAP tries their best to be every step of the way with clients’ everyday life. A client in particular mentioned to me how much MAP helped him even when he strayed away for the straight and narrow path. To watch the relationship that case workers had with this one client express this was not just a facility that catered to those who have AIDS/HIV, they are also a family oriented project. Once he walked in everyone knew he and did not ask what was wrong, but more of what could they do help the solution.
A line/ question that I like and kept me thinking and I felt screams students in low – income areas as well as those who are suffering from deadly diseases need more than a few donations and fancy ideas. “For me [Canada] the big question in America is: Are we going to try to make this country a true meritocracy? Or will we forever have a class of people in America who essentially won’t be able to compete because the game is fixed against them?”
From Louise:
Wednesday, February 23, 2011
Whatever it Takes
“You grow up in America and you are told from day one that this is the land of opportunity. That everyone has an equal chance to make it in this country and then you look at places like Harlem and you stand there and say, that is absolutely a lie” These were the first words that Canada said in his 60 minute interview with Anderson Cooper. Canada’s motivations are the children who have the odds stacked up against them. Who, through no fault of their own, have been born to an inferior class and are expected to fail and remain that way. He is committed to “save kids by the tens of thousands, because that’s how we are losing them.” I found this article very inspiring. To him, he may not be doing enough to help the community but the way that I see is that he is not only helping the child but future generations as well.
There was a piece of argument that I would have to agree with Canada in regards to public schools. “He believed that the only way to successfully educate poor children in significant numbers was to improve not replace, the public school system.” I am not opposed to charter schools but I am disappointed that the government is not being active enough to improve the public school system. Instead we have to resort to charter schools where only a few students can take advantage of the opportunity.
I found the research on chapter 2 to be very interesting. When I read this article it took me back to the nature vs nurture argument. Is it possible that genes are the only factors that play a major role in a child’s intelligence/behavior? Or can we change that through proper nurturing and education? I think it’s the latter. I am sure there are exceptions like Einstein or Beethoven who may have been born with a certain gift, but for the most part, a person’s IQ can change depending on their surroundings. The proof is in the research. Nutrition, socioeconomic, parental involvement, and many other factors have proven to be huge factors at an early age. To assume that genes are responsible for their failure is absurd and ignorant.
From Dayna: Geoffrey Canada
What a powerful story, Geoffrey Canada’s quest to change Harlem and American really touched close with me. This is a powerful movement that he has begun, reaching out to help these communities that are really struggling is going to put a new face on America. Canada is giving all children a chance to succeed before they are automatically expected to fail. I feel this relates very closely with my service learning experience. These girls who I look at, are of these same children in Harlem. They weren’t given many opportunities to strive and prosper. They weren’t given as many chances to succeed as other children were. In result, they have bigger struggles of not only not finishing their education but also raising children at such a young age. Related with the quote Canada said, "The people who run prisons in this country are looking at our third-graders. They look at their test scores each year to begin to predict how many prison cells will be needed twenty years from now." (p.15). As Denise researched and found, the reasoning behind this is that “until third grade, children are learning to read. After third grade, they are reading to learn.” If these children fall back on their reading after third grade, they are put at an extreme disadvantage for all the years to come. This then causes these children to drop out of school and thus creating this cycle which pours more children into prisons, indicated John Morgan, a child psychologist and Executive Director at Voices for Virginia’s Children. To me, not knowing how or why the teenagers that I work with at the Teen Mom Center, are in their situations, its easy to think that as young children perhaps they were not striving through school and were only getting farther and farther behind, resulting in majority of them attending Oracle School and some striving for their GEDs. They could have used a school like Harlem’s Children Zone. Of course I’m not saying these girls are headed for prison, I’m just stating that closer attention needs to be paid to these early years of education. Children need to be encouraged and guided. I feel a school like the one Geoffrey Canada has created is the answer that we need, across America.
Dayna Reilly