Tuesday, September 28, 2010

Teacher as Student

Paulo Freire, in his book Pedagogy of Freedom, particularly emphasizes the relationship between teacher and student and the appropriate dynamics of this relationship to promote freedom, curiosity, mutual learning, and knowledge. He claims that in order for a teacher to teach, they must be continually searching and open to learning alternatives to their established knowledge. He also claims that students must be encouraged to integrate their personal curiosities and experiences into the curriculum to properly absorb the material.
Freiere explains, "When I enter a classroom I should be someone who is open to new ideas, open to questions, and open to the curiosities of the students as well as their inhibitions" (Freire 49). Freire insists that the role of a teacher is one of critical involvement, not simply the transfer of knowledge from teacher to student. The mechanization of education is inauthentic and ineffective. The teacher-student relationship must be constantly open to interpretation and change, interacting with the material on a level beyond lecture and repetition. Teachers must promote students to interact with the subject material in a curious and questioning way. There is no room for real intellectual growth if a student is put on the same conveyor belt of education as everyone else, with no opportunity to explore divergent paths and alternate methods.
However, it is not only important that students question and interact with academic material as it is taught, but to bring their own experiences and backgrounds into the classroom. This provides students with a real base of experience from which to build knowledge from. Freire says, "It is my conviction that the difference and and the distance between ingenuity and critical thinking, between knowledge resulting from pure experience and that resulting from rigorous methodological procedure, do not constitute a rupture but a sort of further stage in the knowing process" (37). Students should use personal experience and curiosity in the physical world around them to begin a discussion that will inevitably lead to a gain in knowledge. This knowledge will be recognized as applicable as opposed to knowledge that is 100% based in the classroom.
Teachers and students have equal obligations to overlap each others' position. The student must sometimes ask the questions and the teacher must allow these questions to shape their direction. However, in this situation, it is the teacher who holds the majority of responsibility in nurturing these curious tendencies in students and encouraging them to question the material and relate it to their own personal experiences.

Tuesday, September 21, 2010

Seeing Ourselves As Part of “The Big Picture"

In Everyday Ethics and Social Change, Peterson argues “Our particular bonds to places and to individual people and creatures must be connected systematically and rigorously to other issues so that we understand the larger structures and processes that shape not just our lives but the lives of the human and nonhuman others in our midst” (150-151). By living we are connected to the outside world and all of our actions affect not just our personal lives, but also our community and public lives. Peterson goes further to say; “We cannot strengthen what we value unless social conditons make it possible” (151). In other words, in order to have the life we want- i.e. a good family, positive human and nonhuman relationships, etc.-we must reach out to our community and actively do things for it, so that social conditions-i.e. distruction of nature, detachment from community, etc-allow us to live thriving personal and private lives.

In order to prove that “lived ethics” work, Peterson discusses thriving Nothern European nations who only work 35 hours a week, but are well set economically and have high quality of life. Peterson says “the ability to live well without either over-consuming or creating large disenfranchised groups is not an unrepeatable miracle, but rather the result of human decisions to embody shared ideas” (152). Northern European countries take public transportation, place importance on education and do other “good” or “right” things and their communities thrive. If we pull together and share similar ethical ideas, our communities will flourish.

One thing that I must remember while I am doing my service learning, is that I am not participating in a service project just because I’m taking a class where service learning is a requirement. Instead, I want to look at this project as an opportunity for me to strengthen my personal life (that is so easy to become consumed with in college and as a young person) by reaching out to my community. In the future, I hope to live my life and do my work with the idea of acting through “lived ethics” and see myself as part of the bigger picture.

Change in our worldview and our society

In her book Ms. Peterson says that "Values and practices, desires and structures, are always interacting with and transforming each other; to single out one as dominant or sole factor in any social process reflects a deep failure of understanding(pg.131)." This was interesting to me because it suggests that our values and ideas change with every interaction with the world. Our ideas and values are challenged constantly by the environment and people we interact with. Just because they are challenged does not mean we have to change our beliefs, it may actually strengthen them, but it forces us to question things we previously held to be true. I think its great to be forced to think, especially when we can get caught up in keeping up with our lives and not really thinking about them. I also like to think we have the potential to grow, think, and change as much as we want. Our worldview can change everyday, making life a lot more interesting. I know I am not the same person I was even a year ago. The new experiences in my life have forced me to change my way of thinking constantly and to look at things in a different way all the time.

The author talked about how Brown v. Board of Education unpopular at the time, but it created the necessary social change. The author went on to say "Perhaps an environmental Brown v. Board of Education could help bring our practices into accord with our expressed values." This interested me because we need dramatic social change to stop harming the planet. So far we as a society have not been up to the task of making necessary changes in the way we live. Ms. Peterson talks about the structural issues blocking change such as current laws and the cost differences in sustainable energy and unsustainable energy. We need citizens to elect people who can change the structure of the government. Without the leaders in government working for change in the government we cannot expect dramatic change in our lifestyles that would lead to sustainability. I thought it was interesting that citizens can affect the world in a large way, but they don't feel they can do anything.

A New Way of Thinking

The current fashion that is sweeping the world is the concept of "going green". Conservation, recycling, sustainable consumption: all of these concepts have been advertised as the steps we all should be taking so that we can heal our world. Thus most people proclaim that they are environmentalist whose values lie with the preservation of the earth. However, as Anna Peterson expresses in her book Everyday Ethics and Social Change, "the gap between what people say they value and the practical choices they make about how to spend their time, energy, and money can be explained in part by the structural obstacles to 'walking the talk'"(141). This "disjuncture between values and practices"(110) is the major cause for the disregard we have for nonhuman nature. The finger cannot be pointed to a specific people or groups; the bottom lines is that the whole of society needs to work together in order to change the way we think about our actions towards the environment and the community. Since initiative is a major factor that contributes to social action, if a value is not already present in a person or group that compels them to "do the right thing", certain social supports and peer pressure can stimulate these habits. For example, Peterson states that "environmentally responsible behavior builds social capital, and social capital makes environmentally responsible behavior more likely"(122). This mimicking of moral correctness is one step that can be implemented to connect people to each other and live by a "collective ethic"(150). The other problem is that people are not willing "to adopt sustainable practices that seem to subtract from their quality of life"(123). This concept is also a problem in terms of helping out in ones community; since we are "self-interested" people, if the activity takes away time and energy from one's own life, the likelihood of participation drops. In my personal experience that I have had with service learning, I have found that there are rewards that can be received and that can work as stimulators for public good, whether that is the natural world or the human community. Last week when I drove out to visit a mom with new twins, my hour trip was rewarded when I saw the look of joy and gratitude on the mothers face from the cribs that we brought her. The best part of that experience was having her just talk to us about her children and how she choose their names; it made me realize that people have different backgrounds, different economic situations, and have different ways of thinking, but every woman who becomes a mother is connect through that relationship to her children. This is the part of the practice based ethic that Peterson talks about when she says that "we construct an ethic based on the values we enact in our most meaningful encounters with other people and with nonhuman nature"(150). The connection that I made with this woman who was grateful for our assistance will shape the way my ethical compass turns. "Recognizing ourselves as part of larger communities and processes, natural and social, is a form of transcendence that generates both humility and hope"(155).

-Ilaria Guerra

Enjoying The Right Thing

Unfortunately, in today's society, doing the right thing is often perceived as making a choice that is much more difficult than the wrong one. People should minimize their reliance on cars, but biking and public transportation are viewed as too much of a hassle. People should become more involved in community gatherings and activities, but they have their own families to worry about. People should inform themselves on current political issues and vote as engaged citizens, but this takes too much effort and feels pointless in the scheme of things. These are just a few examples of ways that people do not do what they know to be right because it always feels like a sacrifice.
In our culture, making some sort of personal sacrifice often correlates to a moral victory. A person gives up one of their hard earned dollars to a homeless beggar and they feel as though through their sacrifice they have bettered the world. Peterson writes, "...people enact moral values only when consciously acting 'on principle,' most often when deliberately curbing desire or sacrificing self-interest" (133). However, this system of sacrifice-based morality, can only get us so far. When issues become bigger, and the necessary sacrifices also become more serious, less and less people are willing to act morally. A person may give a dollar to a homeless person, but they will refuse to alter their consumer lifestyle to support a healthy environment.
What is necessary to create a society in which people spontaneously act in moral ways because of their relationship with their community and the environment around them, not to act upon a personal sacrifice. It would surely be a long, difficult transition, but it is the only way that the majority of people will act in a moral way in small as well as large situations. If there is no concept of loss or sacrifice in making a decision, then people will always opt for the moral answer. Peterson says, "...ethics rest on, or at least are intimately tied to, interpersonal connections and knowledge of others..." (Peterson 133). A society based on the interconnectedness of human nature and the world we live in will naturally give rise to ethics without negative notions of self-interest or self-sacrifice.
Truly, this idea is strongly connected with Siddhartha, in that he viewed all people as one, and all time as together. There is no me or you, or past or present. Everything is everything. If we can invest ourselves in this ideal, then moral decisions should come easily. It is no longer a sacrifice to give the homeless person a dollar if I can honestly realize that the homeless man and I are the same.

Words

Going to the Miss California International Pageant earlier in September was an amazing experience, but the value of this summer's preparation has benefited me in more ways than one. For the past few months I have studied, trained, and perfected the art of purposeful speech for timed pageant interviews, learning how to make every word count. When I came back to school Thursday morning, I couldn't reconcile the aimless conversations between students, friends, and family with the committed phrases and careful attention to language I had heard in competition the week before.

In today's society, we don't view our words as purposeful tools to incite action; more commonly, we don't view them as anything at all, throwing them around with whatever thoughts are in our heads and hoping that most of the time the fly in the direction and with the intention they were meant. Unfortunately, with a system that is built on freedom of speech and clear written rules, our tendency to view the actions we can control as meaningless as our speech brings many Americans, at one time or another, into a contradiction of values. Civic responsibility has become an ambiguous concept, and as Anna L. Peterson narrates, "our culture and institutions educate us to desire ways of living that contradict our efforts to live out moral principles" (p. 125).

Thankfully, due to life changing experiences that occurred at the dawn of my adulthood, I have an awareness of the gap between our cultural narrative and my moral beliefs. I became a baptized believer in Christ eight months ago, an action which prompted me to rededicate my life to the example that He had set so many years ago. Selflessness, grace, purposeful action, and commitment became tangible concepts: the Biblical conception of life started with words, my Savior was the word of God, and my understanding of scripture is through the written word, and every single one holds meaning.

As a society, we must "confront and resist powerful cultural norms that reinforce non-sustainable habits and preferences", and we must take that action through the situations and circumstances we can control (p. 121). As a mentor and volunteer in the Big Brothers Big Sisters organization I have learned through the ever watchful eyes of a child what it means to make every word count; the two and a half years that I spent with my little sister made me realize the importance of establishing the act of mentoring in the words I used and the points I made. I couldn't control the weather, her mood, or the passage of our Friday afternoons, but I could control my reaction.

I hope that this reading inspires us all as honors students to not be overwhelmed with the idea of changing the world, because change on a macro scale is not with in the ability or the responsibility of one man alone. However, we could just try to take it one word, one conversation, one extended hand at a time, and then I'm sure that our service learning will create changed hearts.

Monday, September 20, 2010

Larger Than Life

In finding something bigger and more universal than ourselves to care about, we discover new facets of compassion within ourselves, and a renewed "self-realization, a potentially transcendent experience of being part of a larger whole" (154). Peterson argues this approach of "embedded relationality" as a positive alternative to our current practice of ethics, in which we fail to bridge the "gap" between what we say we believe, and what we actually put into practice.

Peterson proposes that nature provides us with an avenue and an alternate reality in which to experience things that are "far larger... than [ourselves]" (155). She suggests though, that the moments we spend in this alternate reality should really become a part of, and ingrained within, our everyday and common human experiences. As much as we find nature transcendent, it too should transcend the borders of the everyday, "mundane" human experience, and become a regular part of our lives, generating "both humility and hope" (155).

The idea of living in a state of awe for something bigger and more profound than our highly individualistic and private lives is also clear in Peterson's arguments for the integration of private philosophies and ways of conducting ourselves into the public sphere. In this sense, we should be able to bring our private and personal experiences in and around nature to more public and pressing "sources of protest, criticism, and energy for political struggles" (155).

In order to achieve real results, Peterson also suggests a path of action involving practice before complete understanding, to "motivate environmental practices even without 'right intention' or full enlightenment" (132). Returning to Peterson's argument of embedded relationality, she observes that "people routinely sacrifice their apparent self-interest for those they love"(134). In keeping with this belief and practice, we should therefore be able to put the needs of the greater good above our own selfish behaviors in order to build a more just and sustainable future society. By finding common threads between what we know to be true and what we desire to be true, we should therefore in theory be able to put aside our solely private endeavors and begin "embodying the immanent utopias of everyday life" (155).


Phillipa Armes