Saturday, September 3, 2011

A Universal Message

What motivates individuals and collectives to kindness/generosity rather than violence/destruction? How does Deo’s story speak to these universal themes in particular ways?

I am reminded of a quote from J.K. Rowling's Harry Potter and the Order of the Pheonix: "We all have good and bad inside of us. It's what side we choose to follow that defines who we really are." Every day we each fight our own battles – whether to help a classmate or ignore them so we stay on top in class rank; if we should trust that the weary man begging for money is truly using it for food or for liquor - and each day I'm sure we can all say there are some things we did that we are proud of, and others not so much.

The question remains, and as the prompt says: what drives us to do one or the other? Julia listed experience and environment as two of our motivations for kindness or destruction. Indeed, these are major factors that affect our personality and beliefs, but there are far more elemental traits, such as human empathy and the innate need to relate to the world around us, that are tied to our choices of good and bad.

If we sat down and thought about all the decisions we made in one day, no matter how small, I think we could eventually connect that choice to an act reflecting kindness or violence. In turn, that action would reflect an image of us. Most people, including me, would analyze an act and ask, “Why did they do that? What would I have done differently?” We ask ourselves these questions because we are all drawn towards understanding and relating. In Kidder’s novel, Nancy states, “I believe it is human to hope to find order and a connection between one’s soul and the world outside.” (168) Her belief manifests itself in Deo’s return to Kigutu and in his drive to create a better health care system for his family, friends, and fellow citizens.

Some would call his acts compassionate or philanthropic, and they are right to do so. But, I believe there are more to his acts than mere adjectives can describe. Kidder commentates, “…trying again to build a clinic must also be a way, I thought, for him to reach back to his former life and connect it with his new one.” (228) Deo’s actions, his story, reflect the universal understanding that we are all tied to relate and to connect with one another, which further drives our decisions towards kindness or destruction.

From: Julia Hand (and by the way--don't forget to title your post!)

What motivates individuals and collectives to kindness/generosity rather than violence/destruction? How does Deo’s story speak to these universal themes in particular ways?

In general, I don’t think human nature guides people towards acts of generosity and kindness. Of course there are exceptions to everything and a range that individuals span, but more often than not self interest plays into how people act. Personal motives impact whether or not someone will act.

Referring back to the original post, the second to last quote incorporates the idea that “we learn through trial and error, through the process of thinking and acting and thinking” (188) which plays into the idea that through personal experiences people learn that a life filled with kindness and generosity is more fulfilling then a life surrounded by violence and destruction.

I would think Deo learned this first hand as, in part one, he fled from his home country of Burundi fearing for his life. As Deo leaves Burundi for the first time he realizes that “for the lucky few with tickets, an airplane was just the fastest, safest way out. It was flight” (3). The violence between the Hutu and Tutsi groups impacted Deo in a way one couldn’t imagine had they not experienced the same destruction. Though malicious decapitations and merciless killings Deo saw the great amount of pain and suffering that one human could inflict upon another and because of his personal experience he could see that life without violence was much more pleasant than life with violence.

This concept not only applies to people fleeing genocide situation, but in everyday life. I experienced it first hand, last week on my first night of Service Learning with Canal Alliance. I wasn’t sure if I was going to enjoy the SL aspect of the course because it takes time away from other priorities such as studying. It’s two less hours I have every week to relax, hang out with friends, watch a movie, work, go to the gym…it could be anything. However, when I arrived, the other participants were upbeat, motivated and excited about being part of the program. Then the students arrived, and in the two or so hours I spent helping them refine their English, they must have thanked me five times for taking the time to help them. The students were really appreciative and so sweet that I am looking forward to going back next week. This positive environment shows me the fulfillment that helping others can bring and will subconsciously influence my decision to volunteer in the future.

Those two hours were productive, not only for the students, but provided me with a sense of accomplishment as well. By experiencing the kindness and generosity of others and seeing how my positive actions can make a difference, makes me want to continue building on the positives in my life. Through experiencing kindness and generosity I can see that I want my life to include more positives and therefore fewer negatives.

The destruction I have experienced did not leave me feeling the same way. Violence does not create a comfortable environment, so when people learn by experiencing they can see the negatives that violence and destruction causes. Through experiencing, living and reflecting upon situations, most humans would be drawn towards the positive. They learned through trial and error the consequences of negative actions and the rewards of positive actions. The knowledge gained by experience gets people to act in selfless ways, therefore motivating kind/generous acts.

-J.Hand

Saturday, August 27, 2011

Prompt for Text Reflection: Strength in What Remains and video about the image on this blog!

What motivates individuals and collectives to acts of kindness/generosity rather than violence/destruction? How does Deo’s story speak to these universal themes in particular ways?

( Below, is my own reflection on this question but it is also a prompt. Take whatever you want and build on it with your own ideas and tie into other parts of the text. Or use your own examples.)


For obvious reasons, I was very intrigued by Deo's attraction to and experience with philosophy at Columbia (181-188). Throughout the book, Kidder illustrates the ways in which Deo's story manifests the "philosophic mind" that finds the "strength in what remains" of Woodsworth's poem that is the epigraph of this book (look on the page before the table of contents). I am drawn to these few pages about his time at Columbia, because of their explicit ties to this class but also because of the way they show the sophistication of Deo's understanding of "good" and "evil"--of his ability, despite all of his traumatic experiences to neither forgive or blame but to try "to understand what had happened to me" (182). To be the Thinker rather than the Reactor and in that way to begin to formulate a response through action. These few pages bring up many important themes--pick one (from what I list below or something of your own choosing or even continuing to draw the thread of the themes/questions we used in the last class), find other places in the book that connect and why you are drawn to this aspect of Deo's story as told by Kidder.

Deo's argument with the professor about human rationality versus animal "instinct": "How could the instructor say that all animals were stupid, that they didn't think, that they had no free will? Maybe we human beings didn't understand their languages. Maybe we hadn't evolved that far. . .What about Rwanda, what did that say about human rationality?" (185). There is a lot embedded here including the fact that he was in an educational environment where he could even have the possibility of challenging and engaging "authority" in this way. (Also note that we will also be reading Hannah Arendt on Eichmann and the "banality of evil" [186]).

His thinking process about the "catastrophic violence" he had experienced is very significant. He sees human misery as a root cause for the "evil" that had ensued, "a precondition too often neglected by scholars: little or no education for most and, for those who did get it, lessons in brutality; toil and deprivation, hunger and disease and untimely death. . ." (187). Deo's ability to grapple with his own trauma on such a philosophic level is remarkable: "even the leaders, he imagined, were probably deeply unhappy, exercising power that had no basis except guns and machetes, so as not to become victims of power themselves, so as to survive" (187).
This is not an excuse for those who took up machetes instead of saying, "no", but a way of understanding that lifts him out of that cycle of survival, to a different way of being and moving forward.

The idea of doubt of not being rigid in one's thinking or ideology. Deo said that through philosophy, he trained his "mind to be flexible. . . to leave room for uncertainty." His point about there not being formulas and that we learn through trial and error, through the process of thinking and acting and thinking. Also his closing point in this chapter about finding his own "peaceful corners" (188).

JR - EXTRAIT "WOMEN ARE HEROES", Kibera, Kenya by JR

Saturday, August 13, 2011

Welcome to Fall 2011!

Each week, I will post a prompt to help you delve into the readings and connect to service with your community partner. For your response (text/service reflection) can start your own post or post as a comment under my prompt. Please feel free to comment and respond to the reflections of your classmates. Please try not to wait until the last moment before class to post! You will enjoy reading other students posts, so be generous, take a leap, and post your reflection sooner than later. Leapers will be greatly appreciated--but, of course, be thoughtful and use the prompt. If you have other ideas/connections--of course, you can ignore the prompt, but stay "on task".

Julia

Thursday, May 5, 2011

The Soul-ution to Struggle! I'm in Awe...

This reading resonated with me because I am living the unfinished life in the classroom as well as my spiritual life. Raised a Catholic, I feel like I have always been seeking menaing much like the traditional Existentialist philosophers. Kirk Schneider brings light to the human struggle in this week's reading and I believe that I can invest in his greater inscrutable, holistic approach.
What Schneider calls the awe-based ethical approach (p.146). He says that much like you can not have a "one size fits all" philosophy in other areas of life, you "can't force a "fits all" ethic to a complex and changing existence" (p.146). On page 147, Schneider explains what he means to be moved. I believe that this is what is the essence of life is one of the main motivating factors for being drawn to the field of psychology. Schneider descibes the capacity to be moved as a "maximal capacity to be impacted by experiences..Secondly, it is the maximal capacity to be impacted by the entire range of human experience, and not merely those aspects which are dramatic or ready-at-hand" (p.147). I feel i get both ends of the continuum in my service-learning commitment. I feel that the Latino males I have worked with are experiencing their maximal capacity of their experiences. They suffer consequences both of their own doing (excessive alcohol and drug use) and those by fate (childhood abuse, being born in a third world country). I believe while I would like to minimize the effect of this side of the continuum, I feel I would be doing a disservice to these men. Without the appreciation of going without and being accountable for their actions, the other side of the continuum may be marginalized. "Struggle jolts the system, dents the armor, and jars the rails" (p.144). I can not help throw in my own idea here of psychological resilience. Schneider describes "the shock and the awakening are only prepatory" (p.144). For my clients at Starting Point in my service-learning commitment, the arrest and jail time serve as the prepatory phase. The true moment is what this author describes as an axiom. It is when an individual "engages with and emerges from" such a preparatory phase.
These men are encouraged to have a faith wrought from their current pain/ situation, but not be confined by their pain (p.147). The irony is that my service-learning is in a jail yet there are so many other ways in the human experience to be free or imprisoned!...

Monday, May 2, 2011

Chris Hedges Speaks on Osama bin Laden’s Death

Note from Julia--I thought this was so relevant to our last reading that I wanted to post it--please note that the notes and prompt for Rediscovery of Awe are below this post. I also just added a video to the end of this post that is an incredible example of two mothers (one of a son who died in the World Trade Towers and one whose son was one of the attackers) reaching across the boundaries of the other through shared suffering and loss of 911.






Posted on May 1, 2011

Editor’s note: Chris Hedges made these remarks about Osama bin Laden’s death at a Truthdig fundraising event in Los Angeles on Sunday evening.

I know that because of this announcement, that reportedly Osama bin Laden was killed, Bob wanted me to say a few words about it … about al-Qaida. I spent a year of my life covering al-Qaida for The New York Times. It was the work in which I, and other investigative reporters, won the Pulitzer Prize. And I spent seven years of my life in the Middle East. I was the Middle East bureau chief for The New York Times. I’m an Arabic speaker. And when someone came over and told Jean and me the news, my stomach sank. I’m not in any way naïve about what al-Qaida is. It’s an organization that terrifies me. I know it intimately.

But I’m also intimately familiar with the collective humiliation that we have imposed on the Muslim world. The expansion of military occupation that took place throughout, in particular the Arab world, following 9/11 – and that this presence of American imperial bases, dotted, not just in Iraq and Afghanistan, but in Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, Doha – is one that has done more to engender hatred and acts of terror than anything ever orchestrated by Osama bin Laden.

And the killing of bin Laden, who has absolutely no operational role in al-Qaida – that’s clear – he’s kind of a spiritual mentor, a kind of guide … he functions in many of the ways that Hitler functioned for the Nazi Party. We were just talking with Warren about Kershaw’s great biography of Hitler, which I read a few months ago, where you hold up a particular ideological ideal and strive for it. That was bin Laden’s role. But all actual acts of terror, which he may have signed off on, he no way planned.

I think that one of the most interesting aspects of the whole rise of al-Qaida is that when Saddam Hussein … and I covered the first Gulf War, went into Kuwait with the 1st Battalion, 1st Marines, was in Basra during the Shiite uprising until I was captured and taken prisoner by the Iraqi Republican Guard. I like to say I was embedded with the Iraqi Republican Guard. Within that initial assault and occupation of Kuwait, bin Laden appealed to the Saudi government to come back and help organize the defense of his country. And he was turned down. And American troops came in and implanted themselves on Muslim soil.When I was in New York, as some of you were, on 9/11, I was in Times Square when the second plane hit. I walked into The New York Times, I stuffed notebooks in my pocket and walked down the West Side Highway and was at Ground Zero four hours later. I was there when Building 7 collapsed. And I watched as a nation drank deep from that very dark elixir of American nationalism … the flip side of nationalism is always racism, it’s about self-exaltation and the denigration of the other.

And it’s about forgetting that terrorism is a tactic. You can’t make war on terror. Terrorism has been with us since Sallust wrote about it in the Jugurthine Wars. And the only way to successfully fight terrorist groups is to isolate themselves, isolate those groups, within their own societies. And I was in the immediate days after 9/11 assigned to go out to Jersey City and the places where the hijackers had lived and begin to piece together their lives. I was then very soon transferred to Paris, where I covered all of al-Qaida’s operations in the Middle East and Europe.

So I was in the Middle East in the days after 9/11. And we had garnered the empathy of not only most of the world, but the Muslim world who were appalled at what had been done in the name of their religion. And we had major religious figures like Sheikh Tantawy, the head of al-Azhar – who died recently – who after the attacks of 9/11 not only denounced them as a crime against humanity, which they were, but denounced Osama bin Laden as a fraud … someone who had no right to issue fatwas or religious edicts, no religious legitimacy, no religious training. And the tragedy was that if we had the courage to be vulnerable, if we had built on that empathy, we would be far safer and more secure today than we are.

We responded exactly as these terrorist organizations wanted us to respond. They wanted us to speak the language of violence. What were the explosions that hit the World Trade Center, huge explosions and death above a city skyline? It was straight out of Hollywood. When Robert McNamara in 1965 began the massive bombing campaign of North Vietnam, he did it because he said he wanted to “send a message” to the North Vietnamese—a message that left hundreds of thousands of civilians dead.

These groups learned to speak the language we taught them. And our response was to speak in kind. The language of violence, the language of occupation—the occupation of the Middle East, the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan—has been the best recruiting tool al-Qaida has been handed. If it is correct that Osama bin Laden is dead, then it will spiral upwards with acts of suicidal vengeance. And I expect most probably on American soil. The tragedy of the Middle East is one where we proved incapable of communicating in any other language than the brute and brutal force of empire.

And empire finally, as Thucydides understood, is a disease. As Thucydides wrote, the tyranny that the Athenian empire imposed on others it finally imposed on itself. The disease of empire, according to Thucydides, would finally kill Athenian democracy. And the disease of empire, the disease of nationalism … these of course are mirrored in the anarchic violence of these groups, but one that locks us in a kind of frightening death spiral. So while I certainly fear al-Qaida, I know it’s intentions. I know how it works. I spent months of my life reconstructing every step Mohamed Atta took. While I don’t in any way minimize their danger, I despair. I despair that we as a country, as Nietzsche understood, have become a monster that we are attempting to fight.


Sunday, May 1, 2011

Precarious Life

"Lets face it, we're undone by each other. And if we're not, we're missing something"...(23)

This is a powerful quote because it is so true in regards to who are and what we are to characterize ourselves a human beings. I find that this is relate able to my service learning because, without the people who I give or offer my service to at the dinning hall at Saint Vincents de Paul, I would almost feel as if I would not be giving back. I realized this morning that I had not been in to serve at the dining hall in a few weeks, due to a number of things.

But when I got back today I realized that I truly had been missed by the staff that I work with. They know me by name and when Bridget, the one in charge of the volunteer staff, had to go to the store, she left me in some what of a responsibility f delegating work to others while she was out to the store for a quick run. She relies on me when I am there because most of the time there are students there who have never volunteered or even possibly do any time of hard work or manual labor at home such as chores so she counted on me to be able to help out with minor details.

Not to say that Bridget would have been a complete bind without me being there, but she was able to depend on me to help put and step up. If we can not rely on other folks to help us then we are missing out on something. We are to depend on ourselves and not wanting to seek the help that others can give us.