Thursday, February 3, 2011
From Tom: "History, more than memory, distorts the present of the past...
That Deo was able to contain an impulse for revenge after going through the horrors of being a refugee, on the run in Burundi then to Rwanda, only to end up back in Bujumbura is exemplified being reunited with Claude, his classmate during an earlier time. "Deo! Are you still alive?" Claude says. Claude continues to tell Deo that all of his family, with the exception of his cousin, is now dead. "God. Okay. Okay." Deo replies, walking in circles around his old dormitory building. Claude walking beside him, saying, "Hey, we can kill too. They also bleed."
I think Deo understands that retribution won't solve anything; it won't bring his family back. When Deo meets up with Jean, whom the locals call a "muzungu" (white person), he is able to win a brief respite. Jean sees Deo, clearly emaciated, and can easily empathize with his trauma. Jean creates a cover story about exporting African coffee for Deo in the hopes of getting him safe passage out of Burundi. "A woman received him at the embassy, a middle-aged woman. She spoke to him in French. He gave her the letter from Jean's father and delivered his lines about selling coffee, but she didn't ask him any questions about that. 'Where have you been?' she asked, like a worried aunt." It was obvious he was on the run.
Most of us can empathize with another person in pain, and it was demonstrated in many places in this text. Sharon, the former Benedictine nun, exemplifies this quality deeper than most. From the sound of it, Sharon was nothing short of a saint. And Deo's intelligence and ethical core was what saw him through this hell and kept him a whole person to the end of the story. Scarred to be sure, but at least whole. Being a lowly cow-herd makes a genuinely noble character in his case.
At the beginning of Chapter 12 there is a great Burundian saying that Deo relates to the author. "When too much is too much or too is too bad, we laugh as if it was too good. You laugh instead of crying. Accidents of birth." Accidents of birth, is right. We don't choose who we are born to. Deo's story could have been mine or yours, the big "What if."
I could go on for pages with this book. I'm grateful that I, and you, are where we are at the time we occupy. Deo could be one of us.
Strength in What Remains
Throughout the book many people show kindness and generosity towards Deo, which is something that he did not see in Rwanda. Deo was greeted with kindness and generosity from many people that were willing to help him survive and further his education. He was not familiar with the lifestyles that many Americans take advantage of. “But then he thought of his parents trying to rebuild their burned house in Kigutu, of his widowed grandmother in Butanza, of his siblings hiding in the forest. And here he is living off Nancy and Charlie and going to an Ivy League school…The words that came into his mind were ‘useless,’ ‘selfish,’ ‘parasite (104).” Many times Deo thought that he was unworthy of his surroundings. We take advantage of the fact that we can go to school and further our educations because we think that it is “normal.” He had to face the challenges of just surviving and continuously thinking about his family. This is a constant struggle for him to understand his own self worth. I believe that many individuals are motivated to kindness in order to feel some sort of self worth, which is something Deo does not understand.
Deo’s questioning of the instructor’s lecture about animals’ and humans’ “rationality” shows a strong connection to the violence that he was surrounded by in Rwanda. The idea of animals being less that humans was unobtainable to him and he questioned what he didn’t agree with. “How could the instructor say that all animals were stupid, that they don’t think, that they had no free will? Maybe we human beings simply didn’t understand their languages. Maybe we hadn’t evolved that far. Maybe animals were laughing at us. If animals killed only for food-as they usually but not always did-then they were more rational than people. What about Rwanda? What did that say about human rationality (185)?” The “human rationality” that Deo is referring to is the violent acts that humans take part in, yet somehow we justify hurting and killing animals. He connects his experiences from his life in Rwanda involving acts of violence that he had been subjected to in order to show that the “rationality” of humans is not any different from animals. The “rationality” of human beings is as simple as nobody wanting violence, but having to do it because they think they have reason to.
Deo's Days
Deo's Days
From Teresa:
His sensitive temperament was introduced as, “The habit of sympathy was a weakness he caught from his mother” (pg. 41). Deo explained his perceptions further. “When someone says something really bad, it really takes me days to recover” (pg. 179). His personal deep feelings of the human condition prevented him from acting repulsively to another person.
Deo described is family life in positive terms: “feeling utterly safe because he was with his grandfather Lonjino” (pg. 31) and “the family was paramount” (pg .35). Sharon recognized this hole where he once had support and responded, “Well, he needs a family” when asked what Deo needed (pg 176). Being raised in a generally affirmative environment laid a foundation for what was possible and a basic human right of dignity.
Another important point of Deo’s childhood was that he was not taught to hate. When Deo asked his father and grandfather to explain Tutsi and Hutu he was silenced, “Don’t you have anything better to think about?” and “this is prejudice! Shut up!” (pg. 37).
He was taught to deal with life, “When too much is too much or too bad is to bad, we laugh as if it was too good.” (pg. 36 & 178)
“Deo refused to give up” (pg 151)
“I was really being productive and participating in the good cause” (159).
From Denise: SOMEONE WHO COULD SEE BEYOND HIS OWN NOSE
Fortunately, for most of us, we will never come close to experiencing the horrors Deo faced while trying to survive his “flights”. But, can we in our own way, better empathize with Deo and others, by feeling we somehow survive our own personal “wars”? “Battling” illness, unemployment, financial struggle, loss of a loved one, illiteracy, loneliness, concerns about grades and school; the everyday dilemmas we witness, can cause us to think as Deo did, “God, I am in your hands.” (191), “Who is left to trust?” (183). As we read Strength in What Remains, and prepare for our service learning projects, recognizing the importance of emulating Sharon, who “yearned to play a little part in the affairs of the world” (173), “offering undifferentiated help to anybody” (174), is imperative. If we allow ourselves to see beyond someone’s circumstances or outward appearances, and believe that “everyone is on a pilgrimage” (175), the inclination to behave as the subway riders who when Deo asked “for help, in French…would walk away, some would curse…making him realize he…didn’t fit anywhere” (163), would be reprehensible. My desire to become an ESL/TEFL teacher is encouraged, seeing Deo’s desperate and necessary quest to learn English. Embracing Deo’s philosophy, “No group of people is really too small to change the situation!”(158), enables us to perhaps discover what Charlie and Nancy found in Deo, “the best thing that ever happened to them.” (171)
Saturday, January 29, 2011
Prompt for Text Reflection: Strength in What Remains Part 2
For obvious reasons, I was very intrigued by Deo's attraction to and experience with philosophy at Columbia (181-188). Throughout the book, Kidder illustrates the ways in which Deo's story manifests the "philosophic mind" that finds the "strength in what remains" of Woodsworth's poem that is the epigraph of this book (look on the page before the table of contents). I am drawn to these few pages about his time at Columbia, because of their explicit ties to this class but also because of the way they show the sophistication of Deo's understanding of "good" and "evil"--of his ability, despite all of his traumatic experiences to neither forgive or blame but to try "to understand what had happened to me" (182). To be the Thinker rather than the Reactor and in that way to begin to formulate a response through action. These few pages bring up many important themes--pick one (from what I list below or something of your own choosing or even continuing to draw the thread of the themes/questions we used in the last class), find other places in the book that connect and why you are drawn to this aspect of Deo's story as told by Kidder.
Deo's argument with the professor about human rationality versus animal "instinct": "How could the instructor say that all animals were stupid, that they didn't think, that they had no free will? Maybe we human beings didn't understand their languages. Maybe we hadn't evolved that far. . .What about Rwanda, what did that say about human rationality?" (185). There is a lot embedded here including the fact that he was in an educational environment where he could even have the possibility of challenging and engaging "authority" in this way. (Also note that we will also be reading Hannah Arendt on Eichmann and the "banality of evil" [186]).
His thinking process about the "catastrophic violence" he had experienced is very significant. He sees human misery as a root cause for the "evil" that had ensued, "a precondition too often neglected by scholars: little or no education for most and, for those who did get it, lessons in brutality; toil and depravation, hunger and disease and untimely death. . ." (187). Deo's ability to grapple with his own trauma on such a philosophic level is remarkable: "even the leaders, he imagined, were probably deeply unhappy, exercising power that had no basis except guns and machetes, so as not to become victims of power themselves, so as to survive" (187).
This is not an excuse for those who took up machetes instead of saying, "no", but a way of understanding that lifts him out of that cycle of survival, to a different way of being and moving forward.
The idea of doubt of not being rigid in one's thinking or ideology. Deo said that through philosophy, he trained his "mind to be flexible. . . to leave room for uncertainty." His point about there not being formulas and that we learn through trial and error, through the process of thinking and acting and thinking. Also his closing point in this chapter about finding his own "peaceful corners" (188).
So many echoes already from our first two class conversations. . . go where you are most curious to go.
Monday, January 17, 2011
Welcome!
If, you have any issues, you can always post under "comments" without being a member--or you can send to me to post.