Tuesday, October 5, 2010

Neutrality of Teaching and Education to immobilize the classes

Should education be neutral? Should society be trying to keep education objective? Freire says that education shouldn't be neutral. "I could never treat education as something cold, mental, merely technical, and without soul, where feelings, sensibility, desires, and dreams had no place, as if repressed by some kind of reactionary dictatorship(p.129)" Freire wants education to encourage curiosity and critical thinking. For him neutrality would be wrong for education. I think our society wants education to be the transfer of knowledge where neutrality would be the ideal learning environment. I would prefer Freire's type of education that encourages thinking rather than knowledge. It is easier to have a student memorize knowledge than to have them think about why or how that knowledge came about, or go a step further and challenge the student to create their own knowledge. Freire's teaching creates students that will seek to change the world rather than accept it how it is.
Our Society may want education to be neutral to keep the dominant group in charge. Freire said, "From the perspective of the dominant classes, there is no doubt of course that educational practice ought to cover up the truth and immoblize the classes(p.91)." The dominant classes control the education of the marginalized classes and that is how they stay in power. Our society needs a ideology change to focus on the poor. Education should be something that encourages people to push themselves for the better. Our education system is failing if we are producing students that are content with the world how it is.

Being Human

In part four of Paulo Freire's Pedagogy of Freedom, he emphasizes the importance of teachers to act as compassionate, interactive, searching human beings instead of methodological robots. Extending Feire's point to a larger social context, I can see the need for more humane thinking and action in many different workplaces and in everyday life. To help put an end to this generation's global plights and encourage a new generation to embrace their human nature, it must be made a priority to increase human dialogue and interaction now.
Freire says, "The open-minded teacher can not afford to ignore anything that concerns the human person" (Freire 127). To disregard the fact that both the student and the teacher are indeed human, containing emotions, desires, tendencies, disabilities and other human features is a mistake. Education can be made as strictly formulated, structured, and impersonal as possible, but this can not stop either the teacher or the student from bringing their humanity into the classroom. It is not something that can simply be turned off. It would be best for both parties if human nature became an integral part of the learning process, using the extra baggage we carry as humans, as opposed to robots, in the most effective way possible. Freire states, "Education as a specifically human action has a "directive" vocation, that is, it addresses itself to dreams, ideals, utopias, objectives..." (100). Neutrality is an impossibility in education. The politics of a lesson plan do not have to be voiced, but they will be personally felt by every student. It is better, then, to create a dialogue that involves the students and their beliefs and experiences into the curriculum. This will help students to engage in critical thinking and inspire a desire or curiosity for knowledge that doesn't have to be forced.
In a larger context than the classroom, Freire's ideas can be used effectively to inspire everyone to allow their humanity to exist socially in action and dialogue instead of only personally. Freire points out, "It is in the context of the work situation that the worker needs to engage in the process of becoming a citizen, something that does not happen as a consequence of 'technical efficiency'" (94). Being a citizen includes taking stake in society actively seeking the greater good for fellow humans. This goal in incompatible with striving for maximum efficiency in any particular occupation. People need to work to become engaged members of society instead of focusing on technical success. This shift in public emphasis would greatly reduce many problems that the world is facing today, as many of these problems came about because of moral neglect in pursuit of success and efficiency. In this way, Freire's ideals can easily be applied to all occupations, not just that of the student.
To become a human again, a citizen, is essential to making a better, more ethical, world to live in. The goals of the education system as well as most other companies needs to shift from efficiency to concern for the lives and well being of others. This is a monumental change that Freire recognizes is idealistic, but the foundation of his beliefs could lead the next generation to become a part of the solution and not a continuation of the problems we face today.

Monday, October 4, 2010

Ideas Noticeably Absent

If “I cannot teach without exposing who I am,” I cannot learn without exposing long held beliefs and motivations to scrutiny, criticism, and revision if not complete rejection (87). In this way, any new experience is both frightening and filled with great opportunity. Most of our beliefs are veiled in what is socially acceptable. Last week during our class, I noticed how we approached presenting our ideas to each other in our race discussion. All of us, scared to be considered racist or ignorant for our interpretations of the situation, declared some sort of relation to a minority group, either through a family’s immigration or ethnicity, before making a statement.  In any circumstance, it would have been a strain in our society to state a belief about race as a white individual, even the impact of race on a white person, without claiming status outside the dominant paradigm. This only serves to continue the idea that the “true” white members of our society are still bias and inherently out of touch with race in America. By hiding behind these acceptable approaches, this misconception seemed to me to be adopted unintentionally from the beginning. In the exposing ourselves, we are easily open for attack. Yet, even noticing these uses of language and patterns brought me a deeper understanding of one aspect of race and how standards in the approaches we take towards race have been deeply engrained.  In placing statements out in the world, they are more easily revised and scrutinized compared to those notions entertained in ones inner thoughts.
“Practice and theory, authority and freedom, ignorance and knowledge…none of these terms can be mechanically separated one from another” (88). If the action and the meaning behind it cannot be separated, the only way to gain and enhance this meaning is to go through the action. The opposite would hold true as well, an action without meaning would be transitory and ineffective without true impact. By acknowledging and reinforcing this bond between experience and conviction, service learning builds a foundation which can be spread and hopefully built upon to create ethical questioning and better citizens. Yet, it is difficult to take time to experience every issue. I would end up with a checklist running around the community. Poverty, hunger, AIDS, health care, education inequality, etc. would add up rapidly. Looking through the practice ballot for the upcoming election, I had to assess support for community issues I have never experienced and am not directly impacted by. While experience is an important strengthener, it is not practical to try to apply this idea to changing minds about every blight in society. The most I hope to take from service learning is that issues are very complex. While I seek to be informed and proactive, I am not a devoted revolutionary or reformer. Yet, I believe my small steps create an attainable change.
Freire's rage against “fatalism, with its flighty postmodern pragmatism” is misplaced (26). Pragmatism is an important part of any approach to change. The difficulty is separating perceived boundaries and restraints, the perceived unchangeables, the perceived inevitability, from the actual, inherent problems. While this route is much more difficult, it is also much more sustainable. To say freedom and equality are not inherently impossible is true. However, even Freire makes concessions about the role of authority, which by definition places a thought, group, or person above others, is necessary to maintain freedom. So, the pragmatism of agreeing to boundaries and rules, creating an authority, is pessimistic in its perception of humanity as in need of guidance and control to overcome evil which will almost inevitably occur between people. Yet, it finds hope in that we can make our freedoms, understandings, and goals stronger, communal, and more obtainable through changing our system of authority, and most importantly, questioning the system at all opportunities.

Circe McDonald

Sunday, October 3, 2010

The Oblivion of Opinion

Friere puts teaching on a pedestal above most things we as a generalized society place within the realm of priority. He holds the positive teacher-student (and reciprocal and omnipresent student-teacher) relationship so highly that he believes it is able to produce such drastic and profound outcomes as instilling within students "a sense of [their] own self-confidence" (85), which seems a rather BIG proposition to me, as a student and artist who has long struggled with my own confidence. Friere suggests that if students are able to see within their teacher a firm and unabashed self confident, opinionated openness, then the students too will feel encouraged to find the same traits within themselves. "Monkey see, monkey do," but with REAL, experienced, and lasting results.

I saw this idea as the seed which Friere then went on raise into his discussion on human "becoming." He states, "the perception the student has of my teaching is not exclusively the result of how I act but also of how the student understands my action." Through observing and actively learning, we come to recognize the same truths within ourselves, until this deep recognition of internalized self perception "becomes a way of life" (90). Learning, in essence, exists "because we are constantly in the process of becoming and, therefore, are capable of observing, comparing, evaluating, choosing, deciding, intervening, breaking with, and making options, we are ethical beings..." (92). To become, therefore, is to be in a constant state of learning, and to learn is to be in a constant movement of becoming. The two are one and the same.

I thoroughly enjoyed Friere's argument of the necessity of teaching children independence and self-confidence in their thoughts and decisions at a young age. Too often we see young adults who are entirely dependent upon their parents and grandparents and other adults in their lives to supply for them the "key" to life. With every decision faced and obstacle met, the adolescent turns to the elders to do the work, make the choices, and pick up the pieces... And we allow this to happen - even applaud it! Friere's view on education is one that I similarly hold: "... emphasize the children's freedom to decide, even if they run the risk of making a mistake, than to simply follow the decision of the parents. It's in making decisions that we learn to decide. I can never learn to be who I am if I never decide anything because I always have the good sense and the wisdom of my mother and father to fall back on" (97).

We learn through experience and exposure. We need teachers and mentors who bring their own lives to the classroom, and who foster environments in which the students can too. We need lasting changes to how we approach education - more doing and less telling. The fostering of creativity must be esteemed, and the masterpieces and failures of each individual and the collective whole must be equally celebrated. "The child has, at the very least, the right to prove the craziness of his or her idea" (97).


Phillipa Armes

When Self Confidence Holds Hands With Respect

The first week's reading of The Pedagogy of Freedom left me unsure as to the ethic of the educator in Paulo Freire's teacher-student relationship. In the chapter "Teaching is a Human Act", Freire outlines the teacher's ethical foundation and gives powerful arguments for a respectful self confidence and "its ability to discuss its own positions, and its openness to reviewing both itself and its previously held positions" (p. 85). If a teacher is confident in their beliefs yet shows kindness and empathy towards their students, their relationship will be based on mutual respect and allow for an educational environment in which knowledge "becomes a kind of passion" (p. 123).

I have been in many situations where being self confident is a bridge between strength in my moral understandings and understanding of the morality of others. As a mentor in the Big Brothers Big Sisters organization as well as a born again believer who is increasingly becoming more confident in my faith, I feel that I can talk to other young adults and community members from the perspective of an unfinished human being. I am constantly growing and evolving, and my experiences and relationships have given me a strong sense of self and an excitement for the future. My faith has given me a renewed vigor for life and re-empowered my passion for mentorship.

With the understanding that I am unfinished yet enthusiastically watching the person I see myself becoming, I am able to be secure in who I am at this present moment; as Freire said, "My security does not rest on the false supposition that I know everything or that I am the 'greatest.' On the contrary, it rests on the conviction that there are some things I know and somethings I don't know" (p. 120). This final piece of the puzzle that he has placed in his description of the ideal teacher-student relationship gives me confidence in a mutually beneficial educational relationship that will help me to mentor and guide others through community involvement and ministry.

The Humanness of Teaching

In this last chapter of his book Pedagogy of Freedom, Paulo Freire explores the idea that teaching is a human act. He also explores the concept of symbiotic relationships. Whether it is between teacher and student, parent and child, man and woman, or just between friends, a healthy and ethically correct relationship should help the individual grow while at the same time helping the other grow in the process of evolving the relationship. We can see examples of this in the natural world with birds picking the teeth of crocodiles and hippopotamus, and small fish getting protection while also cleaning the big sharks. As humans, we have a tendency of forgetting that we need others in order to improve ourselves, and we cannot always do things on our own.

For example, Freire points out that with a teacher and student relationship a teacher "cannot help the students to overcome their ignorance if [they are] not engaged permanently in trying to overcome his own"(89). This applies to all relationships; there is always something to learn from the other person and in teaching something you too are learning something in return. In terms of service learning, we should always be open to improving ourselves as we try to improve others; it is a very human act that we should all be aware of.

Also, life experience is a fundamental tool that can be uses to educate and nourish knowledge in those who have not had the same opportunities. The fact that we all come from different cultures, backgrounds and hold different beliefs and morals makes us not only unique but gives us the opportunity to learn things from others who are different form our own. As Freire says "it is a posture of unconditional respect for the students, for the knowledge they have that comes directly from life and that, together with the students, I will work to go beyond"(94).

Another important section in this chapter, and one that really resonated with me was the section on listening. In this fast paced world, we are so preoccupied with talking and going and never quitting that sometimes we forget the importance of stopping and listening. In a relationship, Freire says, in order to be able to get your thoughts out, you must first listen to those of others so that you may fully get their attention when it is your turn. This also re-introduces the concept of "talking with" instead of "talking to" because a successful relationship has to consist of a communication structure that includes listening, responding and engaging with each other. A point that Freire makes is that "good listeners can speak engagedly and passionately about their own ideas and conditions precisely because they are able to listen"(107). This skill improves the self and enables the individual to reinforce his or her beliefs by taking in new ones and refining their own. One of the things that Jana, my service learning partner, stresses in me is listening to the needs of the families we are trying to help. Nothing comes out of talking over people and forcing your ideas into them if you do not listen to what they need and want so that you can understand where they come from and what their morals consist of.

After reading this book I have come to see the deeper ethical engagement that teaching requires. It made me appreciate the work that teachers do for their students and this book has also opened my eyes to the humanness teaching and learning.

-Ilaria Guerra

Saturday, October 2, 2010

Prompt for last part of Pedagogy of Freedom

In "Teaching is a Human Act," Freire describes many of the ways that teaching can counter ingrained societal views and inequities. At the same time, I believe that everything he says holds true for all of our relationships and how we can all strive to expand ourselves ethically in the world. As Freire writes: "And the more I give myself to the experience of living with what is different without fear and without prejudice, the more I come to know the self I am shaping and that is being shaped as I travel the road of life" (120).
He describes many of the ways and processes that shape the self and others and the attitudes that may challenge and inhibit this "becoming". Explore some of the ideas that interest you and of course, as always, illustrate with or connect to your service-learning experience when so moved!