Saturday, January 29, 2011

Prompt for Text Reflection: Strength in What Remains Part 2

What motivates individuals and collectives to kindness/generosity rather than violence/destruction? How does Deo’s story speak to these universal themes in particular ways?

For obvious reasons, I was very intrigued by Deo's attraction to and experience with philosophy at Columbia (181-188). Throughout the book, Kidder illustrates the ways in which Deo's story manifests the "philosophic mind" that finds the "strength in what remains" of Woodsworth's poem that is the epigraph of this book (look on the page before the table of contents). I am drawn to these few pages about his time at Columbia, because of their explicit ties to this class but also because of the way they show the sophistication of Deo's understanding of "good" and "evil"--of his ability, despite all of his traumatic experiences to neither forgive or blame but to try "to understand what had happened to me" (182). To be the Thinker rather than the Reactor and in that way to begin to formulate a response through action. These few pages bring up many important themes--pick one (from what I list below or something of your own choosing or even continuing to draw the thread of the themes/questions we used in the last class), find other places in the book that connect and why you are drawn to this aspect of Deo's story as told by Kidder.

Deo's argument with the professor about human rationality versus animal "instinct": "How could the instructor say that all animals were stupid, that they didn't think, that they had no free will? Maybe we human beings didn't understand their languages. Maybe we hadn't evolved that far. . .What about Rwanda, what did that say about human rationality?" (185). There is a lot embedded here including the fact that he was in an educational environment where he could even have the possibility of challenging and engaging "authority" in this way. (Also note that we will also be reading Hannah Arendt on Eichmann and the "banality of evil" [186]).

His thinking process about the "catastrophic violence" he had experienced is very significant. He sees human misery as a root cause for the "evil" that had ensued, "a precondition too often neglected by scholars: little or no education for most and, for those who did get it, lessons in brutality; toil and depravation, hunger and disease and untimely death. . ." (187). Deo's ability to grapple with his own trauma on such a philosophic level is remarkable: "even the leaders, he imagined, were probably deeply unhappy, exercising power that had no basis except guns and machetes, so as not to become victims of power themselves, so as to survive" (187).
This is not an excuse for those who took up machetes instead of saying, "no", but a way of understanding that lifts him out of that cycle of survival, to a different way of being and moving forward.

The idea of doubt of not being rigid in one's thinking or ideology. Deo said that through philosophy, he trained his "mind to be flexible. . . to leave room for uncertainty." His point about there not being formulas and that we learn through trial and error, through the process of thinking and acting and thinking. Also his closing point in this chapter about finding his own "peaceful corners" (188).
So many echoes already from our first two class conversations. . . go where you are most curious to go.

3 comments:

  1. From Julia Guevara:
    First and foremost, I must say that I really enjoyed this book. There are many hardships that Deo went through that cannot be compared to anything we have gone through, and yet the way he handles it is extraordinary. Before I read the blog post posted above, the part of the book that really struck me the most, and lingered in my mind was his explanation on how he has been able to handle the catastrophic events he experienced back in Africa. “Some of the stuff I learned was, be willing to know that even when you think you know for sure, always leave room for uncertainty…” (188). It is easier to blame the “bad guys” and retaliate with anger and violence. In his case, he could have grown hatred towards the Hutus but he did not. On the contrary, he built a clinic where most of the people who lived there were Hutus. Somehow he managed to turn a past full of negativity and horror into a positive outcome and make a difference. Even though he never reached a definite answer on why people are the way they are, his quest for it and his education helped him cope with the horrific events he experienced. The way
    he handles his life’s struggles sounds so much easier said than done. If that were the case, we would not have wars and everyone would understand each other. This book challenges us to reevaluate the way we view, think, and act towards certain aspects of our lives.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Julia you are right! I like how you stated that many people like Deo who go through hardships cannot be compared to anything that we go through and still handle themselves extraordinarily. Deo did go through such a struggle growing as a young man in Africa. He was on the run most of his life just to stay alive because he knew that eventually he would make something of himself. Some people like Deo, that grow up with such harsh lifestyles usually want to make something of themselves so that they don't have to fight anymore. Deo worked hard when he came to the U.S. He could have simply became another person in the US working hard and making ends meet for survival or could have been a bum in the streets of Boston and New York. But instead he furthered his studies, graduated from a top university and then partnered with a man who ran PIH (Partners In Health). "They kept in busy, looking after Haitians whom PIH brought to Boston for surgeries, and performing whatever jobs needed doing to support work in Haiti" ( 154) Deo decided to give back to something he had never once experienced growing up in Africa. He choose to give kindness and generosity over violence. In some ways this reminds me of myself. My parents grew up in Haiti and barely even made it through grammar school. I choose to go all the way by graduating from College of Marin and now continuing my studies by attending Dominican to get my BA degree in Business. I could have simply stopped back then I used the excuse of my parents not going to college and so I don't have to either, but I got places to go and people to give my services back to who are less fortunate then I.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Deo's story is amazing. It demonstrates the hope we all desperately want to believe - that anything is possible. I think it is truly remarkable for an individual to view the world as a beautiful place and offer assistance to people in need if they have experienced a similar life to Deo. I was especially drawn to the stories Deo recalled while working for a hospice in New York. Deo reveals a glimpse of his emotional depth when he talks about why he tried to comfort the patients close to death. "Talking to them so that they could die the good death" (157). Deo is able to listen to their life stories and reflect upon his own. "Mostly they said they felt guilty, for having accomplished nothing compared with what they had planned..." (158). This resonates with me because we all have our moments of doubt. We all wonder about the road ahead. What I find interesting is how many people at the end of their journey wish they had done things differently. I guess the one thing humanity shares is finding that ultimate spot, or moment in time, wherein we feel complete, useful, and content. Deo is living proof of someone living the life he loves. When he talked about work and how it felt to walk into the offices of the PIH he said that it had felt like “...one of those transitions he'd read about in Greek myth, when the mortal consigned to the underworld is granted a parole to return to the light” (158). He continued to say that “Walking into that building was like a whole world opening for me. It was like opening my own house...” (158). To read Deo's story and all that he had to endure, and see how he ended up should give everyone hope. Hope to dream for a better tomorrow. Hope to see and perhaps benefit from the generosity of our fellow man. And hope to find our place in the world. “Finally, finally, this is who I am. This kind of work is not just work. It's part of me, my life, me. There is no way of separating that and me. It feels so good!” (159).

    ReplyDelete

Read the comment that came before and see if you can engage it and use this week's reading to unpack the ideas more--or ask a new question.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.